No, that's not right. You and one other can be playing from your library. It doesn't matter whether it's the same game.
This is how MS lost the 1st round of the console war. By not clearing all of this up at E3 and shouting from the roof tops about what you can do with this sort of thing. None of this came across at E3 or their launch event at all. Just crap about the NFL, crap about TV integration, and then a whole bunch of talk about the games (which is a good thing)
Don Mattrick is not a public speaker. Nor is he a techie, nor apparently is he a gamer. He saw what Steve Jobs did with the iphone launches and thought "year i can do that" No Don, no you can't. Jobbs could sell ice to eskimos because he had a gift, an aurora about him that made people listen, and he had a talent for talking up all the good points and not talking about the bad ones.
Don managed to do completely the opposite with their first press event, and then spent so much time at E3 showcasing games (to try and counter the debate that Xbox was now a PVR and not about games) that they left no time to actually go through the console pros that they should have done at the launch event.
I'll await clarification on the 10 people sharing a game rule.
If you think the devs and publishers are going to allow that then you have to be kidding. They have won a cut of resales but will allow effectively 1 in 10 people to actually buy the game and have the other 9 play it for free isnt going to happen. too many loopholes at the moment so expect some "clarification" on this one closer to release. I expect they are letting this one go at the moment as its probably one of the only decent policies doing the rounds for the Xbone at the moment
Thing, is you want this sort of stuff ( the ability to share games with your friends and family) you've got to give something up. That something is the ability to trade games yourself on ebay, and the ability to trade games in anywhere, including to retailers to make massive profits on used games. The reason you now have to be an "authorised" retailer will no doubt be because you have to sign up a contract that requires you to pay money to be part of, which I bet will go back to the developers.
The shop gets a win, because they can continue selling used games, the publisher wins becasue they get money back ,and the consumer wins because they can trade their game in on the highstreet.
Its about selling this to publishers. Let us have people share their games with their friends and family, and in return we'll cut down on the second hand game crap that goes on.
This is the sort of stuff that should have been said at the launch event.
Movie renting, is now more or less a completely digital distribution method
Purchasing songs, is massivel popular via digital. With great exclusives to digital copies and services like spotify.
PC gaming through steam and origin etc.. is largely dominated by digital distribution methods also.
Console gaming had to follow, and it needed somebody to push the publishers into doing it. The XB1 will do that. Just like Hollywood needed kicking up the backside when the home video recorder came out and they said it was the death of cinema. The music industry thought mp3 was the death of music too, until itunes and amazon etc.. started selling really well.