I feel the actual game is amazing, but the content is just terrible. I feel it suffers from not being sure of what it is. It is an mmo, but the world is so huge that you might never see anybody, and if you don't want to you can just play solo and avoid people.
It has very limited benefits to having groups working together, wings is great and all but if the only benefit of more people is be able to take out dangerous signal sources the game just lacks something to me. People always say the game is as fun as you make it and it is only a grind if you make it one.....and i have to ask how these people dont see it?? Good for them that they can enjoy a game with so little in it but i just don't understand. I compare this to Fallout, now i can sit and grind out all achievements and get all completionist on that game or i can play the story, or i can just build my settlement and wonder around doing random quests. Point is i have an option as to how i want to play and the game has the depth to allow it. Elite has no depth, sure you can explore for the fun of it....i have to admit i have tried it and it felt like dying a slow painful death of boredom, but to each their own. I can trade (funnest part is finding new trade routes as that is actually engaging.) to then die a slow painful death of boredom until i can afford a bigger ship to trade in or a ship to fight in...and here i will admit to enjoying it. Fighting is fun, but a vulture is about as fun as it gets for this. An fdl is quite fun to now but anything above this is pointless and hugely expensive, but more importantly just less fun!
The sad thing is this game has so much promise, but it is gonna be years before we see even a tiny bit of that promise realised, and by then most people will have moved on to newer and better things. Take this engine and build me a new X game and i will never look back.
Now for comments like game not needing to be completed, make your own fun etc etc