Steve, really.
People arent watching Who, I'm sure you have picked up on that by now. What you fail to realise is Gary was a massive Who fan who like MANY people view the franchise as completely ruined but still don't want to give up in the hope it might actually improve. You take issue with Gary because you don't agree with him. Well, pretty much the rest of the world does. fair enough, he goes to the nth often but that's what critics do - they are critical. you just dont like it, and the very fact you say you've never seen him say anything positive speaks volumes because he often does, just not about the sinking ships you refuse to admit have been destroyed. That really does say a lot about you.
If Gary chooses to stop watching then that's a massive fan walking away from a franchise he's grown up with. It's a big thing. 'Drinker, who arguable wasn't such a big fan to begin with, has walked away. After his last review he said he's done with it. Honestly, I'm not so sure that's such a good thing (though i don't blame him!) as we need critics like these guys to enable us to build a balanced opinion on these shows next to the paid and obviously biased reviews you'll find elsewhere online and in media. What we don't need is every show having it's own little isolated echo chamber, where everybody who participates loves the show and everything is all roses and blue skies and lush green grass. *PUKE*. I'd rather people call a spade, a spade and be honest. That earns way more respect from me.