Yea, wasn't expecting a significant change since the layout is the same - was hoping 4K would solve most of it (as you mentioned, higher density). LG are moving to RGWB so it could be worth waiting (if they offer burn-in protection, which they currently don't).
Alienware announces the AW2725DF and AW3225QF (worlds first 4k 240hz and worlds first 1440p 360hz QD-OLED monitors - launches January 2024)
- Thread starter Grim5
- Start date
Soldato
Yeah hopefully they do as warranty is likely to be the deciding factor between the majority of the new OLEDS
Caporegime
- Joined
- 18 Oct 2002
- Posts
- 30,831
The coating on these is glossier than the
also hereIf you're talking about the Asus w/the LG panel it turns out it wasn't glossy....
The Asus ROG Swift PG27AQDP 480Hz OLED Monitor is Not Glossy - TFTCentral
Share this contentThis is a quick post to provide an update to a topic that’s been discussed a lot on our X/Twitter feed and YouTube channel. Some early reports coming....[click link for more]
tftcentral.co.uk
Associate
- Joined
- 1 Mar 2019
- Posts
- 430
Yeah I have the DW and I SOMETIMES hear it, but its a non issue for me. Jesus compared with the PG27UQ I had from Asus years ago its basically silent. That thing was absolutely horrid
The raised black due to ambient light really sticks out when you are used to Woled. Dunno if I would call it a dealbreaker, but I'm glad it isn't being ignored as much as last year. When comparing the 2 OLED techs strengths and weaknesses, this is definitely the main weakness of qd. I guess most people moved from ips/tn/va so didn't really bother them. I've used OLED for years and the black raise was instantly noticeable. You certainly don't need a flood lit room or torch shining at the screen for it to happen. As I mentioned earlier, I can see it already raising in daytime, in a room with 3/4 black out curtains closed with the back of the monitor facing the curtains.
The coating on these is glossier than the
also here
The Asus ROG Swift PG27AQDP 480Hz OLED Monitor is Not Glossy - TFTCentral
Share this contentThis is a quick post to provide an update to a topic that’s been discussed a lot on our X/Twitter feed and YouTube channel. Some early reports coming....[click link for more]
Well that is good. More glossy the better for me. I can control light in my office
Using both qd and oled - for qd to have noticably raised blacks, room has to be so bright that glossy woled becomes a reflection-fest - so it really is a moot point.
Soldato
Pretty sure the Alienware has the graphene as well because it's part of the panel at the rear.
Alienware choose to add a fan because they're giving you 3 years burn-in warranty
Nope. As I mentioned the room doesn't have to be as bright as people describe. My woled wasn't a reflection fest. As I said the room was dim. 3 out of 4 black out curtains closed, screen facing away from the windows and lights off. So for my eye its not a moot point. I have no reason to make it up.
Soldato
Now to me that definately sounds like a deal breaker. For me the main advantage of OLED is true blacks. I've had an OLED tv since 2019 and couldn't go back to anything that doesn't give proper blacks. What you describe sounds like a reasonably dark room and if what you describe is accurate I'd probably send the QD OLED back and get a WOLED screen.
As you say I can imagine a lot of people not realising or noticing the raised blacks if it's their first OLED though.
In the dim environment, it is only a very small raise. Point was that it starts to become perceivable even at relatively low light, and doesn't need floodlit rooms and spot lights. The raise would be higher than a tn in those conditions
Id say it depends on environment if it is a deal breaker vs woled. I game in a dark room so I'm happy.Hmm, it must be something very specific about your room or you must be very sensitive to that. I am using AW3423DW in an east facing room and can still distinguish between pure black and 1%gray in broad daylight. LG G3 on the other hand is much less comfortable to use in such conditions due to reflections - maybe I am on the other hand hiper-sensitive to reflections
Yeah I've got a LG 55e7 and AW34 in the same room, no doubt when it is a very bright environment or light directly shining on the screens, aw34 loses the blacks but then the lg oled you can see yourself and your room reflected, which is even more distracting and requires controlling the lighting/angling much more where as not so much of an issue on the aw34, which is better for me. Pick your poison really.
Glossy every time for me. I can control lighting in my office. That said, as a result not had much issue with the Alienware either.
For both monitor types (I have woled and qdoled) if you play bright content like a action movie or a bright colorful video game, the black level of the qdoled is un-noticeable and you don't see reflections on the woled, so basically it doesn't matter.
But what about dark content? What if you watch a horror movie or horror game in a bright room? On the QD OLED you can still see the content, the blacks just look grey but you can still view the image. On the woled you can't see anything, the game and movie is completely unwatchable due to reflections
So in summary if you're watching bright content then it doesn't matter which screen people use. If it's dark content then qdoled can technically still work, though watching on darkroom is preferred but woled is completely unusable with dark content in a bright room
Last edited:
Yep,that was exactly my point. I would rather have slightly raised blacks than "being part of the action"
(by being a reflection on a screen 
)I am also quite excited by the new AG coating on S95D
Last edited:
I'd assume then, on the current LG and Asus 27" 240hz WOLEDs, which have the matte coating, this wouldn't be an issue?
Soldato
Are the Alienware screen coatings classed as glossy or matt? or is it some kind of hybrid?