Hi Tim,
A bit off-topic, but I'd be interested on your thoughts on the 3D, 120Hz, 23" Asus display you mentioned when you power it up and have a go. Is it the VG236H?
When I start my build (after I finish decorating the study/game room/mancave) I was thinking about going down the nVidia 3D Vision Surround road.
I was planning to get 3 x LG W2363D because it got a good review on
3dvision-blog, but I'm worried that the bezel will be hard to work with (in a surround setup) because of the tube thingy on the bottom. Does the VG236H have a thin bezel? How much did you pay for it?
Thanks,
KB.
KingBob,
The number on the Asus box says VG236. The Model Number on the back of the display says VG236. The Version Number on the back of the display says VG236HE. See their spec page
here. Asus doesn't show a VG236H as a product. So, when I was trying to figure out what was what, basically looking at the Newegg and Amazon sites, I figured out that the VG236H had the nVidia 3D glasses and emitter with it and is called a bundle, and the VG236HE didn't have them included. I ordered the nVidia glasses kit separately.
As best I can measure it with a ruler (should I break out my dial caliper? LOL), the side bezels are 17mm. FWIW, that is the same width bezel I have on my two, 22" wide Samsung displays, and they don't get in the way or bother me at all.
I too noticed the good, more professional reviews for the LG. I then checked the Newegg and Amazon consumer reviews.
LG W2363D:
• Newegg: 16 reviews, 10 five egg, 4 four egg, 1 three egg, 1 one egg.
• Amazon: 5 reviews, 1 five stars, 1 four stars, 2 three stars, 1 two stars.
• Total: 21 reviews, 11 at 5, 5 at 4, 3 at 3, 1 at 2, 1 at 1.
• Percent: 52% at 5, 24% at 4, 14% at 3, 5% at 2 and 1.
Asus VG236HE:
• Newegg: 20 reviews, 15 five egg, 3 four egg, 1 three egg, 1 one egg.
• Amazon: 5 reviews, 4 five stars, 1 four stars.
• Total: 25 reviews, 19 at 5, 4 at 4, 1 at 3, 1 at 1.
• Percent: 76% at 5, 16% at 4, 4% at 3 and 1.
I don't know that it is all that accurate a way to rate them, but that is what I did. I then read most low egg/star reviews to see what the problem was, and try to guess if the reason for the low rating was the display's fault, or if the writer was a putz. I ended up deducing that the consumer reviews favored the Asus display. Since you mentioned it, I now recall reading about the "
tube" at the bottom of the LG.
I paid $341.96 US for it at Amazon with free shipping.
Try to remind me to give you my display impressions when you notice that I am up and running with my build. I'll likely forget otherwise.
I hope this helps!
Tim
P.S. I love the way the one 4-star consumer review (the other four are 5-star), about the VG236HE
here at this site complains about there being no USB ports on the display.