Yeah, it's strange with Vettel. He has a reputation for being ultra reliable, and not making many mistakes but I think when he's under pressure he makes an above average number of errors for a top driver. Similarly, he has a reputation for not being able to overtake well, but I feel like he's quite a tidy overtaker when he needs to be. Finally everyone thinks he's an exceptional qualifying specialist. He was in 2011 but Webber beat him I think 7 times last year, which I wouldn't expect Webber to do against a Lewis or Alonso.
So basically, I'm a massive contrarian when it comes to opinions of Vettel.