Sorry but you're both wrong, LED angel eyes on the pre-LCI E9x look absolutely ****. The halos on them aren't designed for LEDs so the light isn't evenly distributed (admittedly it isn't on the standard halogen bulbs either) and it just looks chav. The orange from the halogen is slightly more aggressive and looks infinitely better. Also the LEDs give out far too much (harsh) light, they're side lights, not main beams, they should complement the xenon's, not be "OMG M8 GOT LED ANGELZ INNIT".
No, you're wrong