BRSK

Associate
Joined
21 May 2024
Posts
2
Location
Birmingham
I’ve given my notice to Virgin today and was ready to sign up to BRSK that’s just gone live in my area.

Been reading up and they use CGNAT. I have a fair few smart home devices that I control from outside the home as well as a Ring Doorbell and DVR connected online which I view on mobile when away.

Don’t play any (multiplayer) games online but that could change.

Would I have any connectivity issues given that it’s CGNAT and would it be less secure?

Would the BetterIP Static IP add-on help?

I’m fairly techy but not so much when it comes to networking/port forwarding etc and wouldn’t really want to spend hours setting up/troubleshooting.
CGNAT is only an issue if you genuinely need inbound connections ( where the connection needs to be initiated from the outside. ) It may seem as though smart home devices fall into that category, but unless you know different ( and you would, because you'd have to set something up such as port forwarding on a router or whatever ) then in 99.9% of cases that's not true. There's a cloud service that acts a a broker - your smart home devices use an outgoing connection to hold open a link to this broker service, as does your phone app or whatever you use to control them.... so in most circumstances and for most home users, CGNAT is absolutely fine.
 
Soldato
Joined
23 Jun 2004
Posts
4,706
Location
Blackburn
Would changing to a static ip affect latency in anyway? I don't have a need to connect to my home devices from outside my network but the brsk site it says static ip is better for gaming also. Would a static ip lower ping in games or is that just some marketing spiel?
 
Associate
Joined
21 May 2024
Posts
2
Location
Birmingham
Would changing to a static ip affect latency in anyway? I don't have a need to connect to my home devices from outside my network but the brsk site it says static ip is better for gaming also. Would a static ip lower ping in games or is that just some marketing spiel?
It's highly unlikely... whilst technically the router on their network will have to modify the packets, we're talking nanoseconds. There's likely to be far more of an effect if they route CGNAT and static IP via different parts of their network, but you wouldn't know the details of that and it's just as likely that static IP traffic would have higher latency. Again though it's highly unlikely that you'll notice a difference.
 
Soldato
Joined
12 Feb 2004
Posts
7,289
Location
Manchester
It's been 6 months so far for me. :cry:

Not sure I am going to bother anymore, the reason for ordering it (the main one) has now passed, so happy to stick with my 5G unless they can do it before the summer arrives.
Ordered mine Nov 2022, still waiting! ive just signed up to another 18 months Virgin Media, when BRSK goes live, il have Dual WAN, my PFsense if ready for this glorious day! lol
 
Soldato
Joined
13 Dec 2003
Posts
6,356
Location
UK
Anyone ditch the technicolor and using their own router

I think I might just connect the ONT into my deco xe75 mesh directly
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom