Not in mammals
Caster Semenya could be forced to undertake hormone therapy for future Olympics
- Thread starter dowie
- Start date
Caporegime
Sorry to be a lemon but can someone summarize/ correct me?
They have xy chromosomes but are a woman ?
The Russian boxing federation did a test, of which there is no evidence or results of and disqualified them?
This is all a witch hunt? They are intact a really manly woman.....
Ami missing anything else.
Can't u tell sex from a pee test? Hormones? Not good enough?
Why are all athletes tested for all the basics.?
They have xy chromosomes but are a woman ?
The Russian boxing federation did a test, of which there is no evidence or results of and disqualified them?
This is all a witch hunt? They are intact a really manly woman.....
Ami missing anything else.
Can't u tell sex from a pee test? Hormones? Not good enough?
Why are all athletes tested for all the basics.?
Last edited:
Soldato
I think there needs to be a set genetic criteria of which biological gender can enter each category. If someone doesn't tick all the boxes they can't compete in that section.
There could be additional categories for people who can't compete in the main ones.
There could be additional categories for people who can't compete in the main ones.
So the question was answered, you wanted to discuss in good faith supposedly and yet... [crickets]
What was it you were looking to discuss exactly if you're being sincere there?
Define woman?
No seriously - it depends on what you mean by woman. Their gender identity is "woman" in the same way as "trans women are women".
Biologically they're male though; either their external genitalia had a few issues so a decision was made to raise them as girls at birth (sometimes surgery is involved) or it wasn't noticed at birth because it looked female externally and so they maybe become aware they were males later - at least by puberty!
No, labs in Turkey and India conducted tests, it's not a witch hunt and the labs are ones the CAS is happy with.
You could call them manly women depending on your definition of woman but they're biological males.
Last edited:
If I smashed would it be gay? I mean it'd be hard to say if the balls touched or not, if they are deep inside her gut.Define woman?
No seriously - it depends on what you mean by woman. Their gender identity is "woman" in the same way as "trans women are women".
Biologically they're male though; either their external genitalia had a few issues so a decision was made to raise them as girls at birth (sometimes surgery is involved) or it wasn't noticed at birth because it looked female externally and so they maybe become aware they were males later - at least by puberty!
No, labs in Turkey and India conducted tests, it's not a witch hunt and the labs are ones the CAS is happy with.
You could call them manly women depending on your definition of woman but they're biological males.
Define please. I think you've just ruined your own argument here
Caporegime
Cool still makes no sense 
Lemme break it downCool still makes no sense
StriderX believes there are three genders.
Male.
Literal Male.
Female.
Cool still makes no sense
OK, to put it simply - it's a bloke (or rather two blokes) fighting in women's boxing and lots of people are just trying to be polite about it (because.... woke LGBTQIA stuff.)
Caporegime
looool
I prefer hypothetical Male.
Soldato
Last edited:
Soldato
- Joined
- 11 Sep 2013
- Posts
- 12,440
As usual, Sillimu makes **** up and kicks off with a childish response....
Where in that post have I said anyone is "incorrect" regarding this topic? The fact that you read such things into it, just as I said people would, only suggests a considerable insecurity in your own opinion.
I wasn't asked for suggestions or solutions, nor was I asked to improve anything - The poster just wanted my own personal perspective.
If ^that's what you want from me, ask away...
Making **** up again, but OK...
Until there is a consensus, rather than just going back and forth with rulings, it IS a can of worms, and nothing in the thread thus far has suggested otherwise.
Private information should remain private. That's the whole point.
Keeping it private does not hurt anyone. Please do explain where you got that idea from!
And yet you appear to be stalking me, despite having accused me of the same, while desperate to get your own words and boots in and again doing what you complained about by offering nothing in the way of solutions...
If you just want to derail the thread, that's fine, I'm always game for a fight.
But do consider taking it to PM next time.
Define woman?
No seriously - it depends on what you mean by woman. Their gender identity is "woman" in the same way as "trans women are women".
A woman is a human being who is able to give birth to offspring
Caporegime
so infertile woman or hysterectomy is ....
Soldato
- Joined
- 11 Sep 2013
- Posts
- 12,440
Equipped according to factory spec at the point of production.
Incorrect again.
Am I not allowed to exist in any thread where you are active? Complex much...