Brilliant epic game Finished my 1st playthru after 22 hours with the default Knight class. Only negatives I can think of are:
Some major areas are missable you need to follow a guide really a lot of content is hidden away & or requires devious ways to access it. I used this one: http://uk.ign.com/wikis/dark-souls-3
Difficulty in places is excessive you really need to spend hours farming souls then upgrading stats to a high level until your ready to face some of the more extreme bosses. It does not end with a boss fight some areas have loads of mini bosses you have to beat every time you want to even retry the boss fight!
Maybe if you had ditched the guide and explored you would have solved your issues.