*** Dell UltraSharp U2410 24" Widescreen LCD Monitor @ £447.99 inc VAT ***

Seems that a few people are expecting their new or replacement screen tomorrow. Me too - Dell phoned to say I can expect it tomorrow (30th). I still have my faulty (green/pink) one too, so it will be good to do a comparison.

Here's hoping.
 
Actually we can't really compare, for example in UK, someone is earning £2000and in the US $2000. At the moment now DELL US site is selling $599, so actually you getting it cheaper which is £447.99. Gotta compare apple to apple. a dollar for a dollar :D

Although it's maybe a little unrealistic to expect "perfection" at this price point, I pretty much agree with your sentiments. Dell are massively overcharging the UK for this screen compared to much of the rest of the world (which pays under £300 for the same screen), so the least they can do is give us some better quality control for that extra money! I don't think it's too much to ask that, when you pay almost £450 for a screen, you at least get no dead pixels and no (major) uniformity issues. Major in my books means something you can notice during normal computer use without actually having to go looking for it.

I was checking a thread about the newer Apple 24" displays though (the ones which use LED backlighting) and noticed they still suffer from things like green and pink tint uniformity issues, so it seems like it's perhaps something related to the actual panels LG makes rather than the lighting on the screens. I'm guessing part of the problem is the vast majority of LG's panel production is for TV's, and the green pink uniformity issues don't really present the same issues for TV usage, but are very easy to notice in computer usage because a lot of the time we're looking at things like plain white backgrounds on webpages etc.

Anyway, I have another U2410 coming tomorrow, so I guess I'll be finding out if it is too much to ask pretty soon. Fingers and toes and everything else crossed. These screens are really good if you can avoid one with the uniformity issues.
 
Actually we can't really compare, for example in UK, someone is earning £2000and in the US $2000. At the moment now DELL US site is selling $599, so actually you getting it cheaper which is £447.99. Gotta compare apple to apple. a dollar for a dollar :D
That sort of understanding is flawed on so many levels it's difficult to know where to start - so I won't ;) Suffice to say pretty much nothing about this screen, except the warehouse staff and the courier, involves the UK. If you want to rationalize the irrational, by giving reasons for why it's ok to charge the UK almost double what most other regions of the world pay ,then that might explain why Dell can get away with it :) Although Dell's US list price is $599 they've already offered the screen with a 20% off in the US (which was the equivalent of £288 at the time of the offer) and will do so again I'm sure.

Oh btw, earlier I said the US gets its screens from China, but it appears many of them are assembled in Mexico, just to correct myself..
 
Mine just delivered, 2 dead/stuck pixels right in the middle of the screen. Will Dell replace?

Does it matter if they won't? You can return it to OcUK within 7 days thanks to the distance selling act.

I'd contact Dell first and see what there turn around is like then contact OcUK.

I'll be gutted if mine has any stuck/dead pixels as i didn't pay £400+ for that kinda QC
 
I've been an hour on the phone between Dell and OCUK. Driving me mental. Dell don't think they have an account with OCUK. or not since 2008! costing me a fortune
 
PLEASE TELL ME HOW YOU GOT YOUR REPLACED? IV NEVER HAD A PROBLEM IN THE PAST WITH DELL BUT THEY ARE REFUSING!!!!! OCUK WONT ANSWER THE PHONE EITHER.
 
Ah, Dell. Still throwing out their flagship monitors with flaws. I dumped my 2408WFP last year I had enough of it's issues.
Well (in fairness to Dell) apart from some people having dodgy buttons and poor stand alignment (which seems an easy fix) the only major issue with these panels seems to be the green pink tint issue. Although I think Dell should be a lot pickier about what panels they're allowing through, not least in the European market where they're charging a large premium, the main issue appears to be with what LG is providing companies. So, if you go with other screens like the HP, or even the Apple LED IPS screen, you appear to face exactly the same problems..

Anyway, a new U2410 arrived. No dead/stuck pixels. There is, however, a mild green tint at the bottom of the screen. This is nothing like the other screen I posted about where the problem was what I'd regard as severe. This time it's definitely harder to notice. It's still the same basic issue - the left and bottom of the screen are coloured differently from the top and right. Colours at the bottom are greener than the top, and the top is a little washed out by comparison. This time it's mild enough that I know for sure some people simply wouldn't spot the issue unless it was pointed out to them.

However, being such an expensive screen, it's something that'll have to last me a few years at least, so I need to decide whether I'll be ok living with this issue for that long. I'm leaning towards giving up, but the realization that this appears to be a common problem with IPS technology, and the fact that I'd face the same issue with the other brands unless I'm prepared to pay a LOT more, means I'll need to think about it more than I should. I just can't be bothered with the constant annoyance of having to change panels with Dell.

For those curious here's a boosted picture.. (keep in mind the saturation is boosted to +88 in Photoshop to show the problem better and you are not looking so much at the pink, but rather which areas of the screen aren't pink, or are visibly darker or brighter).
3rd_DellU2410_GreenTint.jpg
 
most upsetting thing................2 stuck pixels but lovely whites and no pink tint at all! when my replacement comes it'll have 3 stuck pixels and a pink tint no doubt.............oh and suspicious fingerprints all over the screen.

it's like the 2405, 2407wfp, 2407wfp-hc, 2408wfp all over again...............why do we put ourselves through this misery!!!
 
wow, depsite my pixels it is truly stuuning compared to my 2407wfp-HC. in sRGB mode it is just perfect.

Don't be put off by my ranting...........just be patient and keep replacing til you get a good'n.
 
Just had a quick blast on mine when i went home at lunch and my word it's nice :D need to figure out how to put it into "through-mode" or what ever it's called the allows a faster response time.

But it's very nice! Could only test it on my 360 tho
 
Bought one of these yesterday from ocuk and wow its nice! Everything is so crisp and the colours are gorgeous. Makes my 2407 look a little ... um ... old lol ;) Mine seems perfect, no tinting, no stuck/dead pixels. Very pleased so far.
 
it's like the 2405, 2407wfp, 2407wfp-hc, 2408wfp all over again...............why do we put ourselves through this misery!!!
Won't hear a word said against the 2407WFPA04 - best monitor they've ever made and they've yet to provide a worthy successor.
 
Last edited:
Won't hear a word said against the 2407WFPA04 - best monitor they've ever made and they've yet to provide a worth successor.

I completely agree, but you obviously didn't have to endure the banding issue on the first two revisions!

For what it's worth, the U2410 is way better.
 
Back
Top Bottom