*** Dell UltraSharp U2410 24" Widescreen LCD Monitor @ £447.99 inc VAT ***

I know this is a random question, but does anyone use the U2410 with a black, glossy cased monitor like an LG in a dual screen set-up?
Why I ask is that I already have the 23 inch LG W2361V and am wanting to get a slightly bigger IPS panel screen to use as my main monitor, am just wondering if they look good sitting next to each other. I know it's a very bitty issue, I'm just very fussy when it comes to looks!
Many thanks in advance for any replies.
 
I hate to be the bearer of bad news but i was reading the dell monitor forums earlier (because i also have a u2410) and a Dell tech posted this :



So basically you're buying a used monitor which was sent back to Dell because it was faulty.

Sorry to drag up this post again, but I just read the above post and had to laugh. My A01 revision U2410 has a manufacture date of just 2 weeks before I purchased it. To suggest all A01 revisions are refurbished / second-hand A00's is utter nonsense. Can anyone really imagine a huge company like Dell selling tens of thousands of used monitors as new items? The bad press and damage to reputation would be immense.
 
I agree, that is nonsense, but I would imagine that they do refurbish/recondition some returned A00 screens to A01 spec. However they would have to meet QC specs of a new monitor, it really isn't anything to worry about.
 
Hi guys,

I've just received the Dell U2410 from OCUK. How can I check (1) what firmware version it is running and (2) whether I have the tint and dithering issues? I'm not an expert on these things.

Many thanks.

It says the revision on the little card you can pull out at the side. I think they fixed the issues with the A01. My A01 is perfect.
 
So have these tint/dithering issues have been fixed with rev A01 then? I assume that everywhere is now selling A01s? If so I might get one, how noticeable an improvement am I going to see going from a Dell 2407WFP?
 
i just got mine a week ago A01 is it normal for the screen to have a white glow looks like backlight bleeding but only noticeable on black backgrounds and mostly on the corner of the screen?

I have no tinting issue or dead pixels just that white glow is kinda anoying was just wondering if this is normal? the glow is much more noticable looking from the side of the screen..

come to think of it i guess it is backlight bleeding is this normal for this panel?
 
Last edited:
Now I am working I am tempted to save up for one of these. However the lottery of good monitors puts me off, I had a nightmare experience trying to find a decent monitor a year ago, one buzzed, that one had super bleed and another had horrific gradient banding.
 
Spoke to them on the phone and they seem to be shipping A01 as they haven't seen A00 for several weeks now. Will let you know when I get it.
 
Just so some of you know, there've been reports of Dell sending out firmware revision A02 U2410's, with a version number of M1F193, in the last 2 to 3 weeks. As well as a report on HardOCP, someone posted this on an Italian forum..

U2410A02.jpg

(Original post here http://www.hwupgrade.it/forum/showpost.php?p=32349783&postcount=3368 )

Supposedly it might contain some improvements specifically relating to video input and better translation of 24 FPS HD content, but there's no firm evidence yet for what the changes might actually be.

Btw - If you get an A02 screen right now that's not necessarily a good sign. Dell often start out by flashing refurbed screens first. So, if you got an A02 screen, it might well be a returned A01 flashed to A02. Shipping screens directly from the factory containing A02 seems to happen some weeks later. In other words, if I got an A02 right now (particularly one with a sticker placed over the original A01 writing!) I'd hope it wasn't a refurb of someone elses problem screen.

I don't think it fixes the 2 main things requiring improvement on the U2410 anyway. The first is that you can run in Game Mode with sRGB/Adobe mode colours by switching from Game Mode to those colour modes without confirming. It appears to change the colours whilst keeping the responsiveness of Game Mode as long as you don't confirm the change in the menu. So it'd be nice if they'd directly add some menu support so people can finally run things like an sRGB Game Mode without this kludge work around required right now to enable it.

The second is a more major change. The colour LUT (Look Up Table) seems like it's only being used correctly from sRGB and Adobe Mode. In Custom Mode you cannot adjust Hue controls below 48 or above 52 without introducing nasty banding artifacts to colours. So Custom Mode doesn't appear to be making any use of the LUT, and thus the range of colour tweaks you can apply (before introducing nasty visual problems) is extremely limited. Worse, the default gamma value in Custom Mode seems to be somewhere between 1.8 and 2.0, which means it's effectively impossible to get accurate colours out of Custom Mode with a gamma value of 2.2. Many users won't really notice they're using a gamma of 2.0. But, for image pros and people who care about colour accuracy and 2.2 gamma etc, they'd probably find Custom Mode unacceptable for this reason. Hopefully Dell will get around to fixing this some day, or at least endorsing some sort of calibration software which gives direct access to the U2410's LUT etc.

As for tint issues, as other have said, the only way for it to be fixed would be for LG to refine their panel production process. It appears to affect all current LG made IPS screens to some extent. In the U2410's case it's probably reported more often because the wide gamut back light makes reds more red and greens more green etc, which means any colour gradation/uniformity problems present also stand out more. It's perhaps further emphasized by the choice of anti-glare coating too. Short of spending a lot of money on a higher end NEC or Eizo screen (with corrective controls for these problems) there's nothing that can be done other than swapping screens until you get one which doesn't have the issue to any noteable degree. Even in the NEC/Eizo case it's not ideal since any screen "corrected" for tint problems would have less contrast than a screen without the issue. The real problem is only a few companies hold the rights to manufacture IPS panels and LG appear to "completely suck" at making large uniform panels for the computer screen market at reasonable cost.

In the U2410's case it's a great screen, so it's worth persevering if you get a dud, although I would also look at the cheaper HP HP ZR24W now too..
 
I bought a Dell S2409W back in October and it was great for the first few months, unfortunately over the past couple of months it had developed a fault where there was a constant line down one side of the monitor, it was even there when the PC wasn't connected to it - so i was sure it wasn't the graphics card.

IMAG0051.jpg


Anyways I finally got round to phoning Dell to see about getting it replaced as it was still under warranty. The replacement monitor arrived today at my work and so waited until I got home to check that it was the right thing only to find it was a U2410f model! :eek: - I can only guess they have no more S2409W's anymore :D

Looking at the rev. version it says A01 / Mfc date of May 2010.

At the moment the picture quality looks really good, will see how it goes over the next few weeks or so.
 
Anyways I finally got round to phoning Dell to see about getting it replaced as it was still under warranty. The replacement monitor arrived today at my work and so waited until I got home to check that it was the right thing only to find it was a U2410f model! :eek: - I can only guess they have no more S2409W's anymore :D

Looking at the rev. version it says A01 / Mfc date of May 2010.

At the moment the picture quality looks really good, will see how it goes over the next few weeks or so.

I had a 2408WFP Rev A00 replaced under warranty and I got a U2410f Rev A01 - May 2010 as a direct replacement :)
 
I just got this monitor and I was lying in bed watching something the the glow on the blacks is annoying me, it's not as bad as TN for watching in bed but it's worse than the S-PVA Hyundai W241D I had before. Is this just a problem with IPS or could it just be a bad panel.
 
Back
Top Bottom