Distasteful vegan TV ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well I eat meat, but would you eat it if you had to kill it yourself?
Yes and I did in my younger days.

I haven’t got it in me. It would disturb me.

It would disturb the majority of people. That’s why we have abattoirs and professional slaughtermen
Having a worked at an abattoir for 3 years and then went back for another 2 :eek: At that time I would not class them/me as professionals! One example, it was a no smoking site, yet when working the late shifts the entire toilet block on a Friday night was covered in green smoke:cry:

That was 20-25 years ago but honestly its not as gruesome as you’d think, for pigs and cows at least. To be honest with myself I am not sure I would have it in me nowadays. Much prefer sat at my desk firing off emails and joining teams meetings. :p

I thought the advert was quite interesting and funny. Free speech and all that good stuff.
 
People are so detached from it really. The OP is crying because he has hard a hard reminder he is eating an animal and he doesn't seem to like it very much.
I know exactly where my meat comes from. I try to buy my meat from a butcher and always buy British rather than low welfare stuff from abroad.

Comparatively, the UK has very high standards of animal welfare than pretty much every other country. I am satisfied with my position and I'm insulted these wallies think I want an unsolicited lecture on the subject
 
And I suspect that would be the case for most people. Does it hurt for people to be reminded that it's actually an animal they are eating, and not something called 'pork' or 'beef' or 'lamb' that just comes wrapped in a nice little package on a supermarket shelf...
I love this argument, yet it conveniently ignores the fact that butchering is one of the oldest traditions known to humans. People haven’t had to routinely butcher their own live stock for tens of thousands of years. It’s not a compelling argument for veganism, as it’s close to impossible we’d ever be in that position.
 
Well I eat meat, but would you eat it if you had to kill it yourself?
Yes. I learnt that lesson at a fairly young age where I had to kill and pluck a chicken. I must've been about 8 or 9? Wasn't exactly something I had planned to do on holiday but I suppose there was a life lesson there.

There used to be a good documentary on BBC3 called Kill it. Cook It. Eat it. Used to get some good audience in-fighting with all of their opinions :D

As for distasteful vegan adverts? Their food is already unpleasant so it makes sense that their adverts are in the same vein.
 
Kudos to the OP for venting about this online, giving the ad even more attention and exposure! You've got people talking about it which is was probably the main aim of the entire thing.
 
I haven’t seen the ad but if people aren’t comfortable with animals being killed for food, then maybe they ought to consider going vegetarian. It is something that I gloss over myself and something that we probably should be reminded of from time to time.

I haven’t given up meat, but I no longer rely on it as the core staple of every meal. Plenty of tasty veggie stuff out there. I had a paneer curry last night, very good!

As for veganism being better for the environment, I’m not sure, but the carbon impact of the meat trade is definitely significant. All things considered we probably would benefit from eating less meat overall.
 
Last edited:
I know where my food comes from, so the advert was just meant to shock. My daughter, her partner and my granddaughter are vegan and have been for over 6yrs. When she first went vegan, there was a bit of "you shouldn't eat meat" but this has stopped. They have proper meals just like the rest of us (yes it is expensive and sometimes a bit bland). This is their choice in life so we go along with it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom