I don't think I'll ever get the appeal of open world games to be honest. I'm only two hours in but just like with the "masterpiece" BOTW I'm finding myself bored with the world already. The dungeons I've found so far (~5ish) have made the chalice dungeons look like hand crafted masterpieces too.
The combat has left a lot to be desired too, it's like the worst aspects of the previous games rolled into one. Ridiculously aggressive enemies, fake out attack patterns, enemies with massive health pools and endless combos, ambush central in the dungeons with a bunch of enemies that bleed you in two rapid hits.
I'll keep going, I've only just activated the level up grace so maybe it'll get better from here, but so far it's almost as disappointing as DS2.