Hi
@baloney @Atom80 ,
Do you guys have a line to the people developing smart manager?
If so, is there any way you can ask them to lift some of the power restrictions when smart manager's fan settings are set to 'quiet'?
Right now if the fans are set to quiet mode the CPU package power gets restricted to 15-17W
https://i.postimg.cc/g0sc07Qp/screenshot-45.png after a couple seconds, and if the dedicated GPU is active its memory clocks are capped to 400MHz regardless of load. (
https://i.postimg.cc/G2NC8njW/screenshot-46.png ) Max practical power draw seems to be around 32W (furmark) for the dedicated GPU in this mode. When both CPU and GPU are loaded this is about 49W. Temperature for me max out around 65C. The CPU TDP cap + GPU memory cap seems to be the way smart manager's quiet fan mode has always worked for the aero 15 v7 and v8 models.
Obviously the intent of quiet fan mode is clear, the power limits are in place to prevent the machine from baking and allows the fans to spin up less aggressively. I think the quiet mode is rather successful at this goal. But in every other fan mode these power restrictions do not exist. For example, I can set the fans to 'customize -> fixed 30%': and in this mode the fans are virtually silent and not effective at all, yet the power caps are lifted and I can run the hardware at 50W + 90W at 90C forever if I really wanted to.
This is sort of paradoxical.
The 'quiet' mode tries to be the quietest by shutting the fans off at idle and ramping them up slowly, and limits performance while doing so.
The 'fixed 30%' fan mode is actually quieter at any amount of load, but the fans do not turn off at idle, and performance is not limited at all.
The 'normal', 'gaming', and 'auto: maximum' fan modes are too aggressive for daily use imo and when idle the fans still spin up, which is why I prefer quiet mode. I just really dislike the performance limiting.
Deep-fan curve mode also forces the fan to be 30% speed minimum, so they never shuts them off.
What I am really asking for is this:
Some optional way (an additional switch or secret button) to raise the 'quiet' fan mode power limits: cpu a little higher (20W? 25W?) and remove the gpu memory clock cap
Or allow us to turn off the fans in deep-fan mode.
The same thing can be achieved manually (quiet mode when not doing much, manually set fans to fixed 45-50% for load) but it would be much nicer to not have to do this every time.
Pretty please?