Soldato
lol wheres the arsenal players?
Greenlizard0 Weekend Football Thread ** spoilers ** [1st - 5th March 2019]
- Thread starter Cosimo
- Start date
lol wheres the arsenal players?
Hes moaning about a law book being used then moaning when it does.
Caporegime
Just acting like everything is black and white in human decision making.
There would be no problems in the world if everyone just followed the written word.
Soldato
well of course ref dont inforce everything from the rulebook but doesnt mean its right.
Soldato
what a match
lukaka should have taken the pen to complete his hat trick
lukaka should have taken the pen to complete his hat trick
Associate
- Joined
- 21 Jun 2004
- Posts
- 1,653
Quoted for the arsenal fans questioning why Xhaka should have been sent off. I think a studs high cynical tackle from behind is as obvious as you get. Completely missed, but arsenal should have been down to 10 at 15mins. A far worse challenge than the rose yellow card.
I think they probably should have all been red cards.
Caporegime
It’s in the rule book!
Both should go for me but i agree, that's a stinker.
Soldato
The person who encroached was vertoghan and who also intercepted the tap in attempted ..
More of a reason why it should be retaken. common sense, if the person encroaching got the upper hand in intercepting a rebound then it should be retaken.
Thats why its in the rulebook.
But hey lets ignore the rulebook shall we as the world is much safer(syria conflict plus other issues in the world?)
More of a reason why it should be retaken. common sense, if the person encroaching got the upper hand in intercepting a rebound then it should be retaken.
Thats why its in the rulebook.
But hey lets ignore the rulebook shall we as the world is much safer(syria conflict plus other issues in the world?)
Soldato
And danny Rose studs on GK in chest lol.
End of the day my overal point was that the ref was very bad and got lots of decisions wrong including the pens
Deary me. The fact is, they both encroached, the penalty was one of the worst ive seen, you had the shot (which if it went in, i guarentee it wouldnt be retaken) and it was saved. You had the chances and Auba fluffed it.
Kanes was a penalty LOL. Hes smashed into him.
Soldato
noope it was offside
Associate
- Joined
- 21 Jun 2004
- Posts
- 1,653
Yea, the offside would mean it shouldn’t have been a pen.
Offside doesn’t mean that you can’t commit a foul and give a penalty (dangerous tackle should and would be a red and penalty regardless of offside), but a push like that is not serious or dangerous so the offside would proceed the later foul. No penalty to me.
Soldato
yp and the offside happened before the foul so you give the first incident which stops play and deems anything else after that meaningless
Spurs scored a goal but was deemed offside and the goal did not stood because the offside happened before the goal scored so same thing.
He isnt offside though is he lol. There is no attempt to play the ball.
"In situation where a player in an offisde position is moving towards the ball with the intention of playing the ball and is fouled before playing or attempting to play the ball the foul is penalised as it has occurred before the offside offence”
The "offside" didnt happen but the foul at all because Kane does not make an attempt to play the ball! Has Mustafi not fouled him, then Kane heads it then offside...he isnt until he makes that attempt.
Soldato
Nope .the ball was played to him Doesn't need to touch the ball to be offside..he attempted to head the ball .that's offside