You realise that when you play extra midweek games it means more tired players, more injured players, less training sessions and players more tired for said training sessions.
There is a huge difference between training sessions and actual match practise.
If Van Gaal is introducing a new system of play, which our current players have never seen, it will take a while for them to adapt. The more games the better. They need to learn to be comfortable in possession in both training AND in matches. Many players do well in training but fall apart during a real/live/actual match. This will also allow Van Gaal to identify the players who can play and those who can't.
With regards to playing too many games - the players already have the ability to play many games and compete for honours in all 4 competitions. These are not 16 year olds. They are seasoned pros, who can play and win many games every season. If they cant - they must be sold.
These players do not need to be treated with kid-gloves.
EL participation would be detrimental for United.. Knuckle down with the EPL first and hopefully be in contention for 4th and subsequently CL football the year after.
The mentality you are describing is D.Moyes, to a tee - 4th place is good enough in the league and no trophies.
4th place wouldnt be good enough for Chelsea, Man City, R.Madrid, Bayern.
And 4th place is definitely not good enough for Man Utd.
The incoming manager MUST compete for all trophies, from the get-go (unlike Moyes).
This is a winning mentality. Our target is to win...not finish 4th.
When Guardiola went to Bayern, he stated that anything less than the treble would be failure. This is the mentality of a winning manager and LvG will be similar.
Let me put it in simpler terms.
Current Man Utd squad + £150M + Van Gaal = 4th in the league in 2014.
The Glazers would likely classify this as failure.
If 4th place was our target, then we'd have stuck with Moyes.