It looks like HL2, if valve had added zombies! HL2Z1
The problem is, the most realistic looking zombie survival game is an absolute shell of a zombie survival game. I spent most of December (200+hrs in 1 month alone!* - havent done that on 95% of my steam list!) playing 7 Days to Die, its certainly no looker, but theres a game in there. Its not flawless, not by a long shot, but there is a game with all the fundamental aspects (base building, crafting, survival, teamwork etc).
* incl a few hours clocked up accidentally in the menus & minimised, 20h max though.
I doubt i'll touch it again for 6 months unless something big gets added (new PvE enemy like AI bandits or aggressive animals) but like people have been saying about WarZ (w/e) you can get a heck of a lot of enjoyment out of something which is far from perfect.
Graphics are important, but only when the rest of the game is worth playing. Hopefully theres more to come from that area in H1Z1, but clearly visuals isnt where the emphasis is, and if they build a well rounded game with all the important elements in there, it should be a decent game.
I see there's also a storm brewing over these 'paid for' supply drops, in that they may contain weapons. They've said you can only buy cosmetic items, definitely nothing P2W. This kinda questions that statement. Apparently the nature of the supply drop will give others on the server the opportunity to race to the location and create conflicts as everyone tries to get the goodies.
As a game feature, im fine with it. When its something achieved by paying for it, not so much. Its not the same as buying an item in a store and it being in your backpack, but its still spending money in the pursuit of gaining an advantage as a direct result, however you slice it.
I doubt i'll be playing this before its F2P, and even then i dunno, doesnt really fit my preference (i'd rather rent a server and play with friends how we want to play, not share a server with similar views/rulesets, even if its all free), if this was regular EA and went to £7.50 in 6mo like they all do, maybe i'd buy it, but the fact that its F2P just seems so counter-intuitive to then pay for it. If it was a decent game, i'd pay, but if they're giving it away for free then why should i?
Either way, i'll be keeping an eye on it, so for everyone elses sake i hope things go smoother than tonight.