Is it me or has driver mood changed about closed cockpit. They seem reluctantly for it now.
I think it's a case of one or two incidents is a freak, but now three have happened (and who's to know whether Bianchi's injuries would have been less severe or different) and we've had another two close calls (Coulthard/Wurz and Grosjean/Alonso) and let's not forget Chilton was hit in the head by a tyre too, and it's starting to get a bit too frequent to be considered a freak - it's a genuine risk.
I get where Hulkenberg is coming from though. If you make the sport more safe the drivers will take more risks due to the lower chance of being injured, but then you'll get more "freak" accidents which can either harm a driver, marshal or spectator. I can't remember if it was Jackie Stewart or Sterling Moss who in the 2000s said that F1 was "getting too safe" because drivers will end up taking more chances and having bigger and bigger accidents.
The likes of Villeneuve's accident at Melbourne or the pile-up at Monza, both killing a marshal, wouldn't have happened 20 years earlier because it would have been the drivers injured or killed. We had the two flips in the 90s of course (Patrese and Fittipaldi), but they were still rare and one was just a clear miscommunication. (Diniz's flip at the Nurburgring in 1999 doesn't really count as that was just a knock-on effect of Hill breaking down).
The same applies to Bianchi's crash. It wasn't a freak accident - the chances of him hitting the tractor weren't great, but the track has history of exactly that same incident, the light was fading, the standing water was increasing on that corner, yet still the drivers, Bianchi sadly included, continued to drive through there at a merely diminished speed. That wouldn't have happened in the 80s or earlier when the drivers knew safety was a regular issue. That said I'm still furious that Whiting did nothing to take the choice away from the drivers in that situation.
All that said, despite so many instances of drivers being hit in the head by a flying object in such a short space of time, in the cases of Massa, Surtees and Wilson it was just terribly bad luck. Before Massa and Surtees I can't recall any such instances causing a severe problem since Alan Stacey was killed after he hit a bird at Spa in 1960. Senna was killed by his wheel and suspension of course, but that was rather different.