Junior doctor strike: Union's pay demands unrealistic, says Steve Barclay

PPE does expire so stockpiling isn't as simple as it may seem.

Also if you said in early 2019 what was about to happen people would have just laughed in your face.
I was thinking more about general health care capacity in the UK more than PPE. We have consistently cut bed numbers, we're massively under the average for hospital beds per capita:


Our system is set up to fail under normal winter pressures let alone unexpected events. ITU capacity is very poor and there's no depth to staff training and equipment procurement to rapidly deal with spikes in demand.

I had hoped the pandemic might have resulted in some lessons being learned but haven't seen any evidence of this.
 
Last edited:
I think pay rises need to be affordable or funded by efficiencies.

I think trying to claim 35% was ridiculous and the union has set itself up to fail for its members.

I also think the unions are trying to use their members, strikes and the public to serve political aims rather than just to get pay rises - although luckily the whole 'new winter of discontent' thing that was supposed to propel Labour into government has failed to materialise.
Do you not think 35% is merely a negotiation tactic, just like buying and selling you start high and end up somewhere in the middle.

In the meantime a flat out no is just costing money that will be gone rather than used for something useful.
 
ITU capacity is very poor and there's no depth to staff training and equipment procurement to rapidly deal with spikes in demand.
there's no staff training full stop. i dismay at the number of times i been to a bedspace with the alarms ringing only to be told "i'm out of my depth" :(
and the fact that corridors are now considered a "ward area"
and the number of hours i wait in ED just to admit a patient to ICU when i could be reviewing other patients
 
sure, if someone's loved one doesn't improve in 48h we'll just turn off the ventilator
better use of resources and more efficient innit?

you can't rush a human body

using that sort of emotive scenario helps no one

how do you think the 35% should be funded?
 
let's call a spade a spade
the NHS is broken, the social contract between the government and the taxpayer/pulblic is broken
the staff working in the NHS be it doctors/nurses/allied professionals are now being used as scapegoats to a broken system and the public is just lapping it up

sad times indeed

how would you reform the NHS then?
 
From your own link:

Mrs Justice O'Farrell ruled that while the use of the VIP lane - officially known as the high priority lane - was unlawful, she found that both of the companies' offers "justified priority treatment" on their merits and were "very likely" to have been awarded contracts even without it.

I think the PPE thing is blown out of proportion, it was very reasonable in a time of a national emergency to drop some layers of bureaucracy when we were competing on the world wide market to get as much PPE as possible into the NHS. Companies that knowingly took advantage and committed fraud should be prosecuted, but the scheme was set up for good reason.
 
A management restructure would be the starter I'd imagine.
I wonder how the health and social care act 2012 went...

Yes agreed - there should be a full review of the NHS and an honest discussion with the public - the NHS in its current form won't survive.
in all honesty (my views my own and doesn't represent anyone/organisation else) i agree

The NHS all-singing, all-dancing (FWIW lol) cannot exist unless properly funded
Either needs to do less (emergencies only, private electives) or paid for by increased taxation(!)
those screaming "but i paid my taxes" don't really know how much healthcare actually costs
 
Back
Top Bottom