Man of Honour
- Joined
- 21 Nov 2004
- Posts
- 46,283
The point at which we’ve also dried out I suspect.
"Just stop oil"
- Thread starter Diddums
- Start date
The point at which we’ve also dried out I suspect.
You've put forward two choices as being the only two possibilities and you've constructed one to be obviously better than the other. That's good for politics in a wealthy country with energy stability, but it's not reality and it doesn't work in a country without wealth and energy stability.
It's currently impossible to power a country (developed or developing) from renewables except in a tiny handful of countries with extremely unusual circumstances. Iceland is the only one I can think of. Very high wealth, very low population, tiny population density, loads of geothermal, loads of hydroelectric possible in a way that doesn't pose a huge risk to huge numbers of people when it fails. Few if any other countries have all that. Certainly not any developing countries.
Even partially using renewables to power a country requires the huge amount of centralised infrastructure you refer to, so it has to be there anyway. Without it you can do some disjointed partially reliable highly localised power generation that provides some power some of the time. That has valid use cases as an add-on to reliable power generation, but it's not a solution by itself and it's a big ask for a developing country that would be much better served by reliable, controllable country-wide power.
Many countries don't have to import expensive fuel for reliable and controllable power stations anyway. But even for those that do the situation is far more complex than the false dichotomy you propose.
It's probably mostly doable in some places (e.g. solar is much more effective in areas that have large amounts of very hot very sparsely populated land) but it requires a huge amount of infrastructure and it requires buying stuff from other countries. It also doesn't do much for providing jobs locally. Unlike, for example, coal mining and running coal-fired power stations. See South Africa for that problem in abundance.
What could have happened in some places was an energy partnership. For example, much of northern Africa is well placed for solar. Much of northern Europe is at least fairly well placed for wind, with some scope for hydro in some places and some scope for tidal in some places. It's technologically possible to build a large excess nameplate capacity (required because the nameplate generating capacity of renewables is effectively a lie) of those things and a transcontinental grid (or a bunch of interconnects between the two continents) and sharing. There would be transmission losses, but they wouldn't be deal-breaking. There would be a high initial cost, but probably an affordable one and it would be worth it. But politics makes that idea impossible.
Soldato
- Joined
- 25 Nov 2005
- Posts
- 12,657
I don't think anybody is saying we won't adapt, it's more, we won't adapt before millions have died
And this is why support for the Police is at an all time low...
Man of Honour
- Joined
- 29 Nov 2008
- Posts
- 13,311
- Location
- London
And this is why support for the Police is at an all time low...
Rare police W
Doesn't want to be an hour late for work so lets get arrested instead???
Almost as bad as this guy:
Last edited:
Soldato
- Joined
- 25 Nov 2005
- Posts
- 12,657
In comparison the protest is barely an inconvenience
Yeah, being that violent is a bit stupid though, I don't condone that.
And this is why support for the Police is at an all time low...
However, the broader point of the Police yet again protecting the protesters is comical..
Well the police should've pulled the protestors aside, and then this guy wouldn't have gone mad
Soldato
- Joined
- 13 May 2003
- Posts
- 8,955
You'll probably find no barrister will defend the guy arrested whilst they fall over themselves to pro-bono the ********* blocking the road.
Soldato
- Joined
- 3 Jun 2005
- Posts
- 3,273
- Location
- The South
Protesting that pees off the public typically has that effect.
Consequences for being late can have a major effect on an employee which would explain why some people are going to the lengths they are to get on with their day.
Shame really, especially as these protests have achieved* diddly squat for the cause other than to demonstrate what peeing in the wind looks like
* Not entirely true, they've helped the Government bolster anti-protesting laws, so...
Last edited:
Soldato
- Joined
- 31 Jan 2022
- Posts
- 3,305
- Location
- UK
Because it's difficult to imagine what that future would be.
Once climate change falls over a tipping point, the future becomes very uncertain for all life on the planet. We could see 99% of all species dying off. What would that leave us? We'd survive, but what would be the point? No planet, no nature, just living to exist in an underground bunker. And it's not like we could come out next Tuesday, it would take millions of years for the planet to recover.
The first tipping point is thought to be around 3 C. We are already half way there...way ahead of the most pessimistic estimates.
Last edited:
This is why they have a cab rank rule; someone has to defend a person charged with a crime for the justice system to function no matter how evil or socially unacceptable the criminal is deemed to be.
Associate
- Joined
- 1 Mar 2004
- Posts
- 2,004
- Location
- Warwickshire
To be fair he was being a bit aggressive/heavy handed but I agree it's overall a terrible look for the police.
The police took an awful lot of flack when they tweeted about it yesterday.
Strangely enough they were a LOT quicker to get the filthy hippies off the roads today
Last edited:
The police took an awful lot of flack when they tweeted about it yesterday.
Strangely enough they were a LOT quicker to get the filthy hippies off the roads today
a lot of them in recent tweets in here look like somebody's gran or grandad in comfortable slacks rather than hippies.
You want to throw some old timers into the Thames?
Does being an old duffer preclude them from being treated the same as the young'uns? Fling them in too I say. A bit more gently though, don't want to break their hips.