[MAFIA] The Thirteen Doctors

And should we be supporting an alliance that votes someone who argues with them rather than trying to find the scum?

The fact that you would rather I stay quiet and move on than analyse what has happened in the game is very scummy behaviour.
 
Shamikebab said:
And should we be supporting an alliance that votes someone who argues with them rather than trying to find the scum?

The fact that you would rather I stay quiet and move on than analyse what has happened in the game is very scummy behaviour.
Click to expand...

The problem for me though Shami was that your massive summary post was the first really useful post. The rest was just negative or arguing with Chris.
 
shorttricky said:
Anti-Pookie Accusations
Click to expand...
That's fair enough, it's your niggle - I won't say I like it, but you're entitled to your completely incorrect assumptions about me. I don't know or even care why you and Leprechaun are arguing over me. Of the two, it has to be said, only you are acting suspicious towards me, in my opinion - but I would say that, you voted for me on the basis of your niggle.

As for your points, I stand by what I said.
Active - good.
Lynching - good.
Participation - good.
Voting all over the place when half the group aren't even active yet within hours of the game starting - inexplicable. Let the game at least get started!

After all that, I read through my quotes that you've listed and I can't see the inconsistency or the problem. I have always said we need to lynch someone every day, especially day one. That said, let's have a little decorum and not vote for three different people in one day, or make multiple votes when the game has barely begun. Rushing out of the blocks, flinging accusations, stating you have evidence and telling everyone what a great job you're doing for the town is suspicious. It's moving suspicion onto everyone else - and that's what I took exception to and started my arguments with chriscubed - who I eventually voted for to try and get him to leave me the **** alone.

As for taking the mick out of Leprechaun (pun intended!), I'll try not to be light-hearted in the thread again - in case that means I'm in cahoots with someone!
 
I disagree but you are entitled to your view. I didn't want to just throw out random guesses like some on here (seriously try and look at the voting pattern now, it's a complete mess. Maybe what some wanted?)

Look how much someone like Brabbinho, Psymonkee or Pudney have shared. Lack of content (incorrect as it may be) would mean they would be getting votes. I'm being picked on because I am the greatest danger to their control of the town.
 
iviv said:
Evening all! Quite a bit's happened since my last post, so going to sift through everything then make a megapost :D
Click to expand...

I have to say Iviv, going back through the thread I see a lot of posts from you on how to play the game, but not a huge amount about the actual players.

You were wrong about 47. I'm not putting that all on you, but you were. Now you're falling out with Shami because he's a distraction, not because you think he's a mafia. It's just as easy to see that as anti-town as Shami's posts.

But then I also get where Shami is coming from - in preparation I read up on a load of mafia games, from a whole bunch of sites. The only games I saw the town do well was when they'd played together a lot (like getting used to a poker players tells I guess) or when town communicated outside of the thread.

We haven't played a lot. You may have a wealth of experience on the mechanics, but you don't know how the players interact in this group. I'm guessing most of you didn't even know I existed before the last game :D

Shami doesn't like being told what to do - I get that. He may have been a bit aggressive about it, but then so have you been. He helped you lynch 47 when you said we needed a lynch. He doesn't like Chris for the same reason - and to be fair, neither did I - but then to be fair to Chris, I challenged him on it and he pulled back.

So far, I have Egon, Chris, Shami and you as town - but to me, you are becoming as much of a distraction as Shami.

I have Pookie and Leprechaun as mafia - Brabhino I'm suspicious of.

The rest I'm neutral to at the minute, but would class as town for now.
 
Pookie Bear said:
As for taking the mick out of Leprechaun (pun intended!), I'll try not to be light-hearted in the thread again - in case that means I'm in cahoots with someone!
Click to expand...

People do like to get very selective with my comments when they challenge me :D

shorttricky said:
You challenge me multiple times on my gut instinct, but only for Pookie - yet you've never said that you think Pookie is town. Pookie joins in the mocking of your NK comment, but then defends you.
Click to expand...
 
shorttricky said:
Sorry for the late reply, for some reason I missed your post first run through :confused:

You've challenged me on my opinion on Pookie numerous times. You haven't challenged other people in the same way.

To me it looks like you know that you and Pookie are on the same team, and the only way that happens is if you are both scum.

My initial suspicions on Pookie were from how he talked about lynching. Firstly, we need to lynch:
Click to expand...

i have challenged other people in the same way, chricubed in the very beginning

Chriscubed said:
Originally Posted by Leprechaun312
whats with the early lynching, Psymonkee hasn't really done anything to hit he's a dirty rotten scumbeeeegggg
Click to expand...
Why are you defending him? Is it because you're also a dirty rotten "scumbeeeegggg"?
Click to expand...
i then responded with the same answer i gave to you when i questioned your vote on pookie
leprechaun312 said:
I'm not defending him, i just want to know why he is being voted, it just looks like iviv has voted him because he wasn't too fussed on playing
Click to expand...
i then kept at Chris until i was convinced he was a townie, i still do. if anything i gave you an easier time like 2-3 posts over your vote on pookie whereas my questioning of chris lasted the entirety of day one until you voted pookie.
 
shot YOU are the one that is pointing the finger at me and saying im scum, and you seem to be very defensive of everything i post directed at you. I have not once pointed the finger at you, nor have i defended pookie other than asking why you voted for him, nothing more than that.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom