[MAFIA] The Thirteen Doctors

Shamikebab said:
So just to get things straight. You have no thoughts on any of the town except me and Egon and your reasoning for that is...we're suspicious of you?
Click to expand...

My thoughts on the other players are neutral. Nothing is significant enough at the moment.

My thoughts on you two are documented. Simplify it if you will.
 
My whole point is Pudney, your thoughts are not documented Four days in and you are neutral on 5 players and the other two the strength of your case is suspicions without backing it up is mafia behaviour. Especially as I have since stated my case against you and you have shared absolutely nothing. Whether you are town or mafia your current behaviour is incredibly anti-town. You seem to want to stifle discussion and are not willing to share your thoughts on anything that is happening.
 
I step away for an hour and it all gets a bit lairy.

Pudney, I'm not sure where you're going with this. It's quite reasonable to have suspicions without really understanding why. It's called a gut feeling and although it doesn't help all that much there's nothing wrong with putting it out there and seeing what others think. There's nothing inherently scummy about it, in fact if it generates the right kind of discussion then it can only be pro-town. If we all just sat here in silence and let the day drift on then that would be scummy. Shami's post list since the last NK makes for some interesting reading in that respect!

Shamikebab said:
With all due respect to Egon, he didn't play that well last game :p
Click to expand...

Hey... I was doing my best! I still blame 47 for messing with my head :p
 
I've also just realised... shouldn't Psymonkee have more information for us? Since he revealed his role to us there has been another night phase. Who did he watch the night Kaiowas was NK'd?

Seems a bit odd.
 
Egon said:
I step away for an hour and it all gets a bit lairy.

Pudney, I'm not sure where you're going with this. It's quite reasonable to have suspicions without really understanding why. It's called a gut feeling and although it doesn't help all that much there's nothing wrong with putting it out there and seeing what others think. There's nothing inherently scummy about it, in fact if it generates the right kind of discussion then it can only be pro-town. If we all just sat here in silence and let the day drift on then that would be scummy. Shami's post list since the last NK makes for some interesting reading in that respect!
Click to expand...

Being challenged shouldn't be an issue. I've happily challenged someone as soon as I see something suspicious. As I've done with you and Shami.

Vague suspicions aren't that helpful, it's all too easy for mafia to agree and jump in because there's no need to back it up. Which is why I'm demanding explanations, especially as it's Day 4. You can look at today in isolation but again that's a mistake, what have people done in the past and combine that, and I've aggressively challenged anything suspicious throughout.

Right now I will say this, voting for a townie isn't necessarily a bad thing, the townies need more to go on as 2/3 of our votes have been for mafia.
 
So yet again I've asked for your case against me and Egon and yet again you've done nothing but said you've challenged us. You've completely avoided the deadline extension issue as well.

You're acting like someone has voted for you when nobody has.
 
Shamikebab said:
So yet again I've asked for your case against me and Egon and yet again you've done nothing but said you've challenged us. You've completely avoided the deadline extension issue as well.

You're acting like someone has voted for you when nobody has.
Click to expand...

I'm not reposting what I've already posted, especially when I've answered you several times. I'm not entirely sure an extension will be that useful as this argument is likely to continue and be distracting for everyone else.
 
What is the negative for the town if we don't extend? It just means we lose another townie in the night without a lynch.

Quote your reasoning please, because I've read the last page again and you have stated nothing, you've just kept repeating "I've already said, I've already said"
 
Can someone take note of my last comment about Psymonkee. I think it's quite relevant and I would like some opinion.

And Pudney looking at something in isolation isn't a mistake. It often helps to break things down into smaller chunks for analysis.
 
Yes I agree, Psymonkee has shared nothing today with regards to his revealed role. But frankly this all boils down to one point against Psymonkee, he's almost entirely inactive.
 
Egon said:
Can someone take note of my last comment about Psymonkee. I think it's quite relevant and I would like some opinion.
Click to expand...

I've raised other concerns about Psy's claim and have also noted he hasn't posted his latest finding - seeing as a power role is prime target to be NK'd it's crazy not getting the finding down in the thread before nightfall. I'm guessing the answer will be no more information though.

Not sure whether to believe Psy's "Because I'm a colassal idiot with no idea how to play this game?" or not.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom