[MAFIA] The Thirteen Doctors

Shamikebab · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:48

Are we sure there aren't 5 more mafia? Because the only people who would not want an extension have to be mafia, there is no positive to ending the day sooner for the town :/

Pudney · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:48

Shamikebab said:
Quote your reasoning please, because I've read the last page again and you have stated nothing, you've just kept repeating "I've already said, I've already said"

Pudney said:
If you have suspicions then interrogate me. As far as I'm concerned posting vague suspicions or niggles is far more mafia. At least Pookies has been able to add some reasoning.

Pudney said:
I have no problems with suspicions based on something. So I'm asking you for something.

Need I remind you of your long drawn out argument with Chris and Iviv where you were upset they had suspicions of you? Hypocritical?

The reason suspicions with no basis at this stage is more likely to be mafia is that it breeds discontent for no arguable reason, and discontent is what the mafia want.

Pudney said:
Oh, and considering you think my response is aggressive and suspicious, again what's changed in your reasoning for this considering you did the same?

Shamikebab said:
I really think both me and Egon should be pretty much immune to suspicion at this point. I can't see any reason why either of us would have voted so quickly for Brabbinho (when at the time the town was heading towards another target) and Yesterday I was second vote for Killswitch. Granted Egon stuck with Psymonkee but I think that was an equally valid vote.

Pudney said:
I've posted my thoughts. I've also said I'm more inclined to lean towards Egon right now as I've already said. On the plus side you seem to be acting more like Day 1/Day 2 Shami right now.

In Egon's case I'm also suspicious of his voting and in particular Day 3 votes.

Shamikebab said:
#correction What is the negative for the town if we do extend

Pudney said:
I'm not entirely sure an extension will be that useful as this argument is likely to continue and be distracting for everyone else.

chriscubed · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:49

Shamikebab said:
Nothing, he hasn't at any point in the game so far. Despite repeatedly apologising nothing has changed.

Also agreed. Not placed a single vote according to the vote tracker...

Only thing is whether you believe claiming "first doctor" before anyone else makes him likely to be town or not.

Pudney · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:49

Egon said:
And Pudney looking at something in isolation isn't a mistake. It often helps to break things down into smaller chunks for analysis.

Which is why I look at people specifically and not one day's actions.

Egon · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:52

Shamikebab said:
Are we sure there aren't 5 more mafia? Because the only people who would not want an extension have to be mafia, there is no positive to ending the day sooner for the town :/

I fail to see the point as much as I fail to see how Psymonkee's continuation in the game is of any use.

Shamikebab · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:52

So you're not voting and you want the day to end so there is a night kill. Your behaviour is just damn odd Pudney :/

You've just quoted posts that say your suspicion of us is because we were suspicious of you, are you seriously claiming that is a reasoned case?

Egon · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:52

Pudney said:
Which is why I look at people specifically and not one day's actions.

You could try doing both.

chriscubed · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:53

Egon said:
One thing I do agree with Pudney on is that it is pointless to extend the day.

Can I ask why? If we're not able to reach a decision for the lynch tonight that's not good news - surely we would be better off with another day?

Pudney · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:53

Shamikebab said:
So you're not voting and you want the day to end so there is a night kill. Your behaviour is just damn odd Pudney :/

You've just quoted posts that say your suspicion of us is because we were suspicious of you, are you seriously claiming that is a reasoned case?

No, I've quoted posts which say I'm suspicious of you because you claimed suspicion on me with no reasoning.

Shamikebab · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:53

Fair enough if people don't want to extend the day then we have to do something. At the moment it feels like only 3 of us want the town to continue. We have several completely active people and one person behaving very anti-town.

##vote Psymonkee

Shamikebab · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:54

Pudney said:
No, I've quoted posts which say I'm suspicious of you because you claimed suspicion on me with no reasoning.

And then I posted my reasoning, so your case has fallen apart? Egon has addressed why posting gut feelings is beneficial for the town. It feels like you are just sticking your fingers in your ears at this point.

Pudney · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:55

Shamikebab said:
And then I posted my reasoning, so your case has fallen apart? Egon has addressed why posting gut feelings is beneficial for the town. It feels like you are just sticking your fingers in your ears at this point.

And I posted that I was less suspicious of you because you'd just given me some reasoning.

Pudney · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:57

Pudney said:
As stated I want reasoning for the pressure. This is Day 4, if you can't give a good reason by now then you should think about your suspicions in more detail which at least you've done with this post.

Although this was lost in my horrendous post I'm unable to edit

Egon · 17 Mar 2014 at 21:58

chriscubed said:
Can I ask why? If we're not able to reach a decision for the lynch tonight that's not good news - surely we would be better off with another day?

Because I don't think it will make a difference. We'll have another day of silence followed by few hours of heated discussion... just like today.

How many have voted for an extension? If that is what the majority want then fair enough. However I stand by my point about Psy, whether he is being honest or not I don't know, but it all just seems a bit odd. But his inactivity does not help us at all.

Pudney · 17 Mar 2014 at 22:00

##vote Psymonkee

I'm still most suspicious of Egon though, at least I've already been suspicious of Psy.

Egon · 17 Mar 2014 at 22:01

As have I. But my previous vote for him was suspicious for some reason.

chriscubed · 17 Mar 2014 at 22:05

Egon said:
Because I don't think it will make a difference. We'll have another day of silence followed by few hours of heated discussion... just like today.

How many have voted for an extension? If that is what the majority want then fair enough. However I stand by my point about Psy, whether he is being honest or not I don't know, but it all just seems a bit odd. But his inactivity does not help us at all.

I disagree on the extra day, but it's a fair explanation.

Psy hasn't voted once in 4 days. Worst case scenario, we lose someone who isn't contributing to the discussion or voting, and getting a voting majority seems like it's getting harder now.

##Vote: Psymonkee

Egon, Shami, Pudney, Chriscubed have voted for him now, I believe this is L-1 - next vote is the hammer.

Pudney · 17 Mar 2014 at 22:06

Egon said:
As have I. But my previous vote for him was suspicious for some reason.

It is, but a kill is more useful right now as the odds are against the town.

shorttricky · 17 Mar 2014 at 22:08

I'll hammer. To be honest, it's one less name for me to take a shot at - I'd hoped he'd watch me tonight just in case, but he's not contributing, so it seems hopeless to rely on it.

## vote Psymonkee

Leprechaun312 · 17 Mar 2014 at 22:39

ahh **** i missed it