[MAFIA] The Thirteen Doctors
- Thread starter JeditOjanen
- Start date
Caporegime
So you'd prefer no discussion? Show me where you have attempted to encourage discussion today and find the mafia. Until I demanded it you have shared basically nothing today.
The feeling I have with you is the same I had with Brabbinho. It feels like you are posting just enough to not 'do a Psymonkee' but that you aren't actually sharing anything useful or trying to find the mafia.
The feeling I have with you is the same I had with Brabbinho. It feels like you are posting just enough to not 'do a Psymonkee' but that you aren't actually sharing anything useful or trying to find the mafia.
Soldato
Because I'm a colassal idiot with no idea how to play this game?
^^Spot on. I wish I'd watched more carefully what I was doing as I could have done some fairly handy work with this power if I'd been paying attention.
Also assuming I targeted the mafia NK as well which early in the game is fairly long odds!
As for today? All I see is some back and forth between Pudney and Shami with some healthy and reasonable suspicion against myself and Shorttricky.
Finding a target amongst this mess should be interesting as I have no idea where to start!
Is voting pattern and order something reliable to actually go on or is it all guess work again?
Caporegime
I have just been through and read all your posts
You initiated the vote for fortyseven with what seemed like pretty much no reasoning at all.
You flip flopped day 1 on whether quiet posters were mafia (starting out by voting Brabbinho because of that, then saying mafia weren't always quiet, then talking about changing your vote to Leprechaun because he was quiet)
This was your reaction to the town lynch on day one:
"Well 47 was annoying."
Yet more flip flopping on day two, you posted this:
"From my experience in the last game, not putting pressure on people is a massive gift to the mafia, putting pressure on straight away is absolutely necessary. This isn't a game where you can sit back and wait for something to become obvious because it won't happen."
Yet you've just had a go at me and Egon for putting pressure on you?
You were questioning the change of vote to Brabbinho on day two (and even said you thought it was the wrong thing to do) then suddenly switched to him with no reasoning.
Your main person of suspicion throughout the game has been Psymonkee and frankly that's a pretty easy target.
There are things in your favour, you have argued against established mafia (noticeably Killswitch yesterday) and you have voted for both, although late for both.
These are some of the reasons I have my suspicions.
You initiated the vote for fortyseven with what seemed like pretty much no reasoning at all.
You flip flopped day 1 on whether quiet posters were mafia (starting out by voting Brabbinho because of that, then saying mafia weren't always quiet, then talking about changing your vote to Leprechaun because he was quiet)
This was your reaction to the town lynch on day one:
"Well 47 was annoying."
Yet more flip flopping on day two, you posted this:
"From my experience in the last game, not putting pressure on people is a massive gift to the mafia, putting pressure on straight away is absolutely necessary. This isn't a game where you can sit back and wait for something to become obvious because it won't happen."
Yet you've just had a go at me and Egon for putting pressure on you?
You were questioning the change of vote to Brabbinho on day two (and even said you thought it was the wrong thing to do) then suddenly switched to him with no reasoning.
Your main person of suspicion throughout the game has been Psymonkee and frankly that's a pretty easy target.
There are things in your favour, you have argued against established mafia (noticeably Killswitch yesterday) and you have voted for both, although late for both.
These are some of the reasons I have my suspicions.
Caporegime
^That was in regards to Pudney.
Of course voting pattern is something to go on, it's foolish to ignore 3 game days worth of posts at this point. You can already see from Day 2 K1LLSW1TCH happily voted with another mafia member - there's no reason not to think he'd do so again, especially when voting is at the early stages.
Caporegime
I really think both me and Egon should be pretty much immune to suspicion at this point. I can't see any reason why either of us would have voted so quickly for Brabbinho (when at the time the town was heading towards another target) and Yesterday I was second vote for Killswitch. Granted Egon stuck with Psymonkee but I think that was an equally valid vote.
Also if we were mafia and knew Fortyseven was town would we have been stupid enough to do either the 6th or hammer vote on him? It would be really poor play.
Also if we were mafia and knew Fortyseven was town would we have been stupid enough to do either the 6th or hammer vote on him? It would be really poor play.
He did something I'd do as mafia. As I said. That's reasoning enough for me.
[/quote]You flip flopped day 1 on whether quiet posters were mafia (starting out by voting Brabbinho because of that, then saying mafia weren't always quiet, then talking about changing your vote to Leprechaun because he was quiet)[/quote]
I made 1 vote on Day 1.
[/quote]This was your reaction to the town lynch on day one:
"Well 47 was annoying."[/quote]
Well it was.
[/quote]Yet more flip flopping on day two, you posted this:
"From my experience in the last game, not putting pressure on people is a massive gift to the mafia, putting pressure on straight away is absolutely necessary. This isn't a game where you can sit back and wait for something to become obvious because it won't happen."
Yet you've just had a go at me and Egon for putting pressure on you?[/quote]
As stated I want reasoning for the pressure. This is Day 4, if you can't give a good reason by now then you should think about your suspicions in more detail which at least you've done with this post.
[/quote]You were questioning the change of vote to Brabbinho on day two (and even said you thought it was the wrong thing to do) then suddenly switched to him with no reasoning.[/quote]
Kaoiwas convinced me.
[/quote]Your main person of suspicion throughout the game has been Psymonkee and frankly that's a pretty easy target.[/quote]
Has he been? I've called out suspicious behaviour and moved on when there is something more obvious.
[/quote]There are things in your favour, you have argued against established mafia (noticeably Killswitch yesterday) and you have voted for both, although late for both.
These are some of the reasons I have my suspicions.[/QUOTE]
Like I say, feel free to vote for me today. Townies can afford the loss of one of them. But don't play the whole "not much has been said by you today" - this is Day 4, there is plenty to look at now.
Last game I had Egon convinced I was Town. No one should be above suspicion.
Caporegime
Not much has been said by you any day Pudney. I haven't seen a single summary post from you where you share your thoughts on the town, fancy doing that now?
Caporegime
With all due respect to Egon, he didn't play that well last game 
No-one should be above suspicion perhaps but it's a wasted effort if the best you can come up with is "sharing suspicions is mafia behaviour" You have yet to share any kind of case against the two of us which leads me to think you are just trying to dissuade attention from yourself rather than contribute meaningfully.
No-one should be above suspicion perhaps but it's a wasted effort if the best you can come up with is "sharing suspicions is mafia behaviour" You have yet to share any kind of case against the two of us which leads me to think you are just trying to dissuade attention from yourself rather than contribute meaningfully.
Not really, I prefer to target my posts specifically. If I'm not asking things about you I'm neutral on you. I don't think anyone is certainly town at this point, because that's a mistake.
With all due respect to Egon, he didn't play that well last game
True, but you'd convinced people as well and they maintained that belief to the last day.
I've posted my thoughts. I've also said I'm more inclined to lean towards Egon right now as I've already said. On the plus side you seem to be acting more like Day 1/Day 2 Shami right now.
Caporegime
So just to get things straight. You have no thoughts on any of the town except me and Egon and your reasoning for that is...we're suspicious of you?
Caporegime
An hour to go, is anyone else voting to extend the deadline? I think only me and Egon have.
Soldato
idk, i dont think we will reach a consensus tomorrow either, you 2 are fighting, the vote against psy and shot is going nowhere and the discussion about our doctor roles has been useless, so why bother extending if we arent going to reach one. Plus i am almost certain if the deadline is extended it only stretches out the 2 NK's, as when the night phase begins, one person is going to be night killed and short is going to shoot me or pookie
Soldato
oh and ##unvote