So you're saying that unless we've played the game, we shouldn't be allowed to form an opinion even after watching it on live streams and YouTube clips? I don't get this place. On one hand you've got people saying that buying a game before watching videos about it to know what it's like is silly, and then others like you are alluding that you can't form an opinion without having played the game first. I'm sorry but I'm not prepared to drop almost £45 on a game when I can clearly see that there are issues, and for me personally, having played the first three and loved them (up until ME3 was butchered), I have high expectations on what a game set in that IPs universe should be like. From what I've seen and read, ME:A doesn't even reach the bar.
No but that is only going to take you say far. I've watched some of the facial videos and also some gameplay streams but they are not really representative of what it is like to play the game (or any game) moment to moment when you are playing it yourself. Maybe it's me but I can't get immersed in a game watching someone else play it at all.
Chances are he is just being defensive about something he is enjoying. As for what he said, I have based my judgement not only on what I have seen, but what LOADS of people have said.
But your judgement is still not based on your experiences of playing the game. And how many of those loads have actually played it for any length of time if at all? Are they really the majority you are basing your opinion on? My issue is that so many people are willing to go into a thread and slate a game based on someone else's comments and videos. I can understand someone saying "This game looks as though it's not going to be for me from looking at videos" but "oh my god this game is crap I knew it was going to be be raaarrrggghhhh" without actually playing it is nonsense (not that you've done that personally but you get the idea).