OcUK Mafia game thread - Game 3

Egon said:
If he was Mafia why would he want a last minute push on Branninho? Mafia wouldn't care who got offed as long as it was a Townie. If Leprechaun wanted a Townie dead the only option to vote for was me as I was the only other person with a vote and would have guaranteed a kill.

Sorry but that explanation doesn't cut it. You swung the axe.
Click to expand...

Perhaps Brabbiho is also mafia and FortySeven made a last minute vote to ensure that Brabbinho would be safe as 2 additional votes for him would be needed at the last minute, thus ensuring his comrade's safety?

Just a thought
 
Last edited:
I didn't need saving as a tie results in a no lynch. So the argument that fortyseven was helping me doesn't ring true. Especially when voting last minute. For me fortyseven committed murder on day 1 and is a member of the mafia.

Also why would the mafia want to bump fortyseven off? To my eyes I didn't see him do anything on day 1 to put him self in danger. So I think that is a ruse on his part.

If Fortyseven is mafia we need to establish the other two.

Jedi I'm not convinced about either way, but his silence on day 1 was interesting.

Pudney thinks Fortyseven is townie. I just wondered on the reasoning.
 
I'm suspecting Jedi at the moment, he said that Kaiowas had improved in the last game and it's possible he saw him as a threat. He also said that I had improved too so assuming I survive a lynching then if I'm killed tonight it's not going to look good for him.

The annoying thing is somebody could just be setting all this up to look that way.
 
Brabbinho said:
I didn't need saving as a tie results in a no lynch. So the argument that fortyseven was helping me doesn't ring true. Especially when voting last minute. For me fortyseven committed murder on day 1 and is a member of the mafia.

Also why would the mafia want to bump fortyseven off? To my eyes I didn't see him do anything on day 1 to put him self in danger. So I think that is a ruse on his part.

If Fortyseven is mafia we need to establish the other two.

Jedi I'm not convinced about either way, but his silence on day 1 was interesting.

Pudney thinks Fortyseven is townie. I just wondered on the reasoning.
Click to expand...

Above is the most telling summary in my eyes - personally I really can't make my mind up on Fortyseven though despite it all, just doesn't quite add up in my eyes :confused:

Looking forward to seeing Jedi's read into the whole town later regardless (sure there's a Jedi joke in here somewhere)
 
Fortyseven said:
Most suspicious thing I have read so far.
I also could be wide of the mark here, but why are you voting Egon then trying to protect him.

Either you are voting for him as you think he is dodgy and other people might see that and agree with you or you are voting for him as you think he is the least suspicious person and are trying to lue people out (however, with the above quote you might fail) or you are both Mafia and it is actually a good way for both of you to get to the night.
Click to expand...

Fortyseven said:
Brabbinho does something you call a "little dirty move" and still he is not in your top 3?
Click to expand...

Fortyseven said:
VOTE: LEPRECHAUN312
Click to expand...

You call Brabbinho out twice then get in a last second vote for Leprechaun? I'd accept you might have made a duff newbie style play if you'd been consistent.

VOTE: FORTYSEVEN
 
Last edited:
Either I made a stupid play by voting last minute and making everyone think I am scum.

OR

I made a stupid play by voting late and proving that I am scum.

Quite frankly I am cursing myself because either play is pretty damn stupid.

I could say that people rushing to hang me are a bit suspect (too me) because only scum will know for sure that I am not, but I know that most will not believe me.
 
Fortyseven said:
I made a stupid play
Click to expand...

Damn straight :D

If you'd voted to lynch Brabbinho, I might have talked myself out of you being mafia.

Voting for Leprechaun seems to have come out of nowhere. That, plus the timing makes me think he's hit on something, and you've made a play to get rid of him. I don't think even you can say that's an unreasonable assumption :D

If you are a fellow townie....sorry man. Like you admit, it's a bad play either way.

I know, I've voted early, but I probably won't be about for a sneaky 21:58 vote ;)
 
Pudney said:
As said, I cannot believe a mafia member would do something that so obviously shouts mafia! Maybe I'm too trusting but on the first day it seems more trigger happy than mafia.
Click to expand...

It's possible that is the case. But it's an obvious defence for him to use too.

Like I said before by ensuring a lynching takes place means the Townies are two down instead of one. They then have a chance to redeem themselves the next day, however bad it may look they could somehow talk themselves out of it.
 
Well I have totally screwed this up, the last thing I wanted was a debate about my guilt.

I said earlier, lynch me if you feel you have to, but as Brabbinho (and some others) have been trying to do, you need to look for other Mafia members.

Anyone who supports me, at this stage, is going to look dodgy.

Use the time productively rather than arguing my guilt.
 
Last edited:
Egon said:
It's possible that is the case. But it's an obvious defence for him to use too.

Like I said before by ensuring a lynching takes place means the Townies are two down instead of one. They then have a chance to redeem themselves the next day, however bad it may look they could somehow talk themselves out of it.
Click to expand...


I suppose it just seems too easy for one of the mafia to have exposed themselves this early really. On a positive note, either way this has led to some interesting responses (and some interesting silences) which is at least piquing my interest in others.
 
Day 1 vote order:

Brabbinho votes Egon (1)
Killswitch votes Leprechaun (T) (1)
Leprechaun votes Brabbinho (1)
Fortyseven votes Leprechaun (T) (2)

So Egon was going to be lynched until Fortyseven posted that Leprechaun vote moments before the deadline. Now people are calling Fortyseven out for that, and suddenly Egon and Fortyseven are on opposite sides. Egon demands an explanation for the vote on Leprechaun, and immediately Fortyseven gives up and acts like he's going to be lynched even though nobody has voted for him and several people are talking me up as a suspect as well. This feels like a bus to me.

I also don't like Egon's case against me - well, I wouldn't, but I don't like it because it's not his reasoning. Brabbinho raised the possibility that I was gaming the Town and Egon latched onto that. As someone deduced, the Scum don't want to NK me if they can avoid it because while I'm alive I look scummy but once I'm dead you'll all know I'm Town (and hence everything I've said is honest). They're much better off trying to raise suspicion against me to get me mislynched, for which they can excuse themselves.

Vote: Egon
 
JeditOjanen said:
Day 1 vote order:

Brabbinho votes Egon (1)
Killswitch votes Leprechaun (T) (1)
Leprechaun votes Brabbinho (1)
Fortyseven votes Leprechaun (T) (2)

So Egon was going to be lynched until Fortyseven posted that Leprechaun vote moments before the deadline. Now people are calling Fortyseven out for that, and suddenly Egon and Fortyseven are on opposite sides. Egon demands an explanation for the vote on Leprechaun, and immediately Fortyseven gives up and acts like he's going to be lynched even though nobody has voted for him and several people are talking me up as a suspect as well. This feels like a bus to me.
Click to expand...

Indeed, but you didn't see me panic voting to save my skin or lynching a townie.

JeditOjanen said:
I also don't like Egon's case against me - well, I wouldn't, but I don't like it because it's not his reasoning. Brabbinho raised the possibility that I was gaming the Town and Egon latched onto that. As someone deduced, the Scum don't want to NK me if they can avoid it because while I'm alive I look scummy but once I'm dead you'll all know I'm Town (and hence everything I've said is honest). They're much better off trying to raise suspicion against me to get me mislynched, for which they can excuse themselves.

Vote: Egon
Click to expand...

Discussion amongst the group led to theories being put forward, some people will then agree with them, some won't. But theories have to come from somewhere. However your absence only fuelled my suspicions further.

Now you are here you don't even bat an eyelid at Fortyseven's last minute lynching and are instead pointing the finger in my direction and the best you could come up with there was "it's not his reasoning". That's pretty weak. And what about the other remaining residents?

Sounds like deflection tactics to me! In cahoots with Fortyseven by any chance?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom