Seriously, no. It's only WoW that has gone on to take a hold of a non-gamer market that nobody else realised was even there.
Fan boys will defend there position without thought or logic. I am a consumer, simple as that. Treat me right and i am sold. In fact, i have been looking for a new mmorpg to play with my other half so i am actually 2 consumers. After this beta, no thanks, i will wait. KOTOR is looking pretty hot.
I haven't disagreed with anything you've said. My points were :
1. Since WoW Western players assume betas are a presentation of a finished product. We/they see them as a chance to get a foot up, gain advantage for release, play for free.
2. Japanese developers don't see this. They presume a 'beta test' is what it says on the tin. Bug finding, optimisation, a chance to take metrics etc
For instance, in the instructions that come with the game it says that the beta client runs like **** and will be full of lag because they are running a huge amount of test code in the background.
But Westerners don't read instructions. They prefer to just dive into a game and learn by experience. So most who complain about lag, particularly with the UI, aren't aware of this.
There are numerous valid complaints, but I can guarantee the client will be different at release. They (SE) have consistently said judge us at release, not on alpha/beta.
One thing that was a deal breaker for me was software mouse so I'm stoked that hardware mouse will be in at release. Also want to see what the timers on guildleves will be reduced to.
As for WoW it did well at release, but it was after release that the market and it's customer base grew virally. (I was in beta, as an aside I was the first lvl 60 on Terenas and possibly the first lvl 60 in Europe). And it was the Far East that saw it really grow. China alone accounts for over half its customer base.
The point is it wasn't the beta that garnered the 'non gamer' market.