One Night Ultimate OcUK Werewolf - Game 1

Egon · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:22

They have been very quiet... they are either watching this play out because we're pointing at the wrong people and if Sami lied about the seer then it's working perfectly for him.

or... they are just busy elsewhere :/

Brabbinho · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:26

We could really do with more time if people are going to be slow to post

Shamikebab · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:30

I'm here, I was busy. Honestly this game confuses me

I think we need an extension really.

chriscubed · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:32

iviv, can we have an extension or is the deadline final?

My main role deductions:
Werewolf 1 K1ll
Werewolf 2 Lep/table
Minion Egon
Seer Short
Robber Shami
Troublemaker Brab
Insomniac Lep/table
Villager 1 chriscubed
Villager 2 table
Villager 3 table

And if you don't believe Shami, this is the alternative IMO:
Werewolf 1 Shami
Werewolf 2 table/lep
Minion kill
Seer table
Robber short
Troublemaker brab
Insomniac table/lep
Villager 1 chriscubed
Villager 2 egon
Villager 3 table

Egon · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:39

another 24 hours?

Brabbinho · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:41

I think you are right with your first deduction Chris. Though it's you or Egon for last villager.

shorttricky · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:46

Sorry, poorly kid took me away.

Personally, I thought Egon was werewolf early on - plenty of talk, but not really saying much.

Kill's "maybe" troublemaker seems very random. No posts since. Hard to think he isn't.

shorttricky · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:50

Did not see page 3.

I'd vote for another 24 hours if we can. I'd rather hear from Lep first.

Plus I'd forgot about the minion, I may need time to rethink

iviv · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:51

Given the incredible slowposting, and general request of the people posting in here, I'll push the deadline back 24 hours, the game will now finish at 10pm tomorrow the 25th.

And here I was planning on running the next game with a day length of just 3 hours to condense it and make it a bit more frantic!

shorttricky · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:55

iviv said:
Given the incredible slowposting, and general request of the people posting in here, I'll push the deadline back 24 hours, the game will now finish at 10pm tomorrow the 25th.

And here I was planning on running the next game with a day length of just 3 hours to condense it and make it a bit more frantic!

Thanks Iviv

Perhaps we'll get better with practice?

chriscubed · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:55

I'm going to vote for Killswitch. I believe Egon was a werewolf, and Kill was minion, and that Brab has swapped them, so Kill is the best target for actual werewolf vote.

I will also ask for an extension in my vote PM

Brabbinho · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:55

For my part it is getting used to the game and the roles. We'll get better!

chriscubed · 24 Sep 2014 at 21:56

Ah, iviv has posted saying we have an extension, sweet.

Actually iviv I think a 3 hour window should work better, it's easier to commit to a few hours than a whole day.

Brabbinho · 24 Sep 2014 at 22:08

I think killswitch is a werewolf but I switched him with Egon. But then Chris thinks Egon is werewolf could they both be?

chriscubed · 24 Sep 2014 at 22:13

I don't see why not?

shorttricky · 24 Sep 2014 at 22:20

Brabbinho said:
I think killswitch is a werewolf but I switched him with Egon. But then Chris thinks Egon is werewolf could they both be?

Maybe - that would be an impressive pick

But....

chriscubed said:
I believe Egon was a werewolf, and Kill was minion, and that Brab has swapped them, so Kill is the best target for actual werewolf vote.

That actually makes a lot of sense - Kill has thrown one really random remark in there that presents him as a target - hasn't defended it. But if the minion dies, the werewolves win.

So if Egon is a werewolf (I reckon he might be), you swapped Egon to minion, Kill to werewolf - Kill is the best...er...kill (sorry)

Egon · 24 Sep 2014 at 22:21

I can't see how that is possible... Kill would have to be a villager if you switched us Brab. Which leaves me with whatever role Kill was... hopeful not a wolf!

As I've said all along, Chris waited very late to claim and then jumped on the villager when he did, in his own words "the villager is the safest claim to make"!

Brabbinho · 24 Sep 2014 at 22:24

Chris waiting late could be read both ways.

If he is the 3rd villager you might wait to call BS on sometime.

Equally its an easy role to pick if you are a wolf

Brabbinho · 24 Sep 2014 at 22:25

Any response from Leprechaun iviv?

Egon · 24 Sep 2014 at 22:33

Yes Brab, you are right, it's impossible to prove either way. Taking Chris's post from earlier,

chriscubed said:
My main role deductions:
Werewolf 1 K1ll
Werewolf 2 Lep/table
Minion Egon
Seer Short
Robber Shami
Troublemaker Brab
Insomniac Lep/table
Villager 1 chriscubed
Villager 2 table
Villager 3 table

And if you don't believe Shami, this is the alternative IMO:
Werewolf 1 Shami
Werewolf 2 table/lep
Minion kill
Seer table
Robber short
Troublemaker brab
Insomniac table/lep
Villager 1 chriscubed
Villager 2 egon
Villager 3 table

The only thing I see wrong with this (other than I'd swap Chris and myself in his first option), is that in the 2nd option it would make Short the werewolf as he robbed Shami so would look something like:

Werewolf 1 Short
Werewolf 2 table/lep
Minion kill
Seer table
Robber Shami
Troublemaker brab
Insomniac table/lep
Villager 1 chriscubed
Villager 2 egon
Villager 3 table