I'm having fun somewhat, just entered the sewers. The game doesn't feel that short because I started on HC and I'm replaying sections to try stuff and play around with dodges to minimise damage. Still, it really lacks some puzzles and cool little places to explore. What's there in the streets is nice but it should be three times the size, really.
Nemesis is terribly implemented and I'm actually glad he's not stalking for longer periods in this game as he's just plain annoying instead of being scary. He can outrun you and two-shot you to the back when you can't see him so I'm forced to either turn the camera around and risk running into stuff/zombies or go out of my way to stop him. And it doesn't help that Jill won't go through doors if I'm not facing them exactly right so yeah.
Maybe I'll get my money's worth for the 20-something quid I paid but I really don't think I'll replay this much. The game's structure, pointless cinematic segments and lots of cutscenes make me think replays are going to be tedious, especially on Inferno where I'm going to get stomped every minute.