Poll: Should Gary McKinnon be extradited to the US for hacking?

Should he?

  • Yes

    Votes: 232 19.5%
  • No

    Votes: 823 69.3%
  • I don't like poles

    Votes: 132 11.1%

  • Total voters
    1,187
Personally i think he should be extradited for breaking the law, plain and simple.

The only thing im iffy on is the length of time, and whether there would any leniency shown towards his disability, to me the crime does not fit the punishment being doled out.

The chances of him getting 70 years is probably pretty slim. It will just be the maximum possible sentence.
 
...
As poster boys for injustice go, he isn't doing overly well considering he is actually guilty.
No need to waste time and money on a trial then; RDM has passed judgement.

Just ship him off to Guantánamo Bay then, just as the Americans have done with so many other people.
 
No need to waste time and money on a trial then; RDM has passed judgement.

Alternatively, Mr Sarcasm, it is because he has admitted doing it. But hey lets not let the truth get in the way of yet another cheap shot. God you are pathetic at times.

Just ship him off to Guantánamo Bay then, just as the Americans have done with so many other people.

Yes because that happens so often with high profile extradition cases...
 
Gary McKinnon's final appeal against extradition to the USA for breaching the security of 97 computers allegedly controlled by the US Department of Defence, the US Navy & NASA will be heard today.

He is accused of being a terrorist, conducting "the biggest military computer hack of all time" and causing damage to the tune of $800k; he faces up to 70 years in jail and some deranged US officials have even called for the death penalty.

Gary who has Asperger's Syndrome claims that he was searching for concealed evidence of UFOs and the UK Government have refused to try him here.
 
Surely the person in charge of security should be imprisoned for being utterly useless. Guy stays over here, STFU USA.
 
Last edited:
Well that's great, their systems were hacked by a kid with Asperger's, surely the person in charge of security should be imprisoned for being utterly useless. Kid stays over here, STFU USA.

"Kid"? He's 43 years old! :rolleyes:

And I don't know why everyone keeps harping on about the fact that he's got Asperger's, as if that makes any difference to anything. It doesn't impair his moral judgement, and it certainly doesn't place him above the law. I've got Asperger's, and I don't use it as an excuse whenever I do something wrong. It's completely irrelevant to the case.
 
Keep him here, let him get two kills under his belt and promote him to 00 status

The yanks only want to extradite him so they can clone him and or use him to hack everywhere else for them.

/foilhat
 
Death penalty for hacking?

Come on U.S, how ***** up is that?

He's not being threatened with the death penalty. Or Guantanamo Bay. Or any other stupid idea.

He's lost, going by BBC report just now.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/8177561.stm

Fantastic news, it's about ****** time. The irony is that if he'd pleaded guilty in the first place, he would have received a token sentence and probably been out by now! But no, he tried to lie his way out of it by denying the charges. n00b.
 
... Asperger's doesn't impair moral judgement ...
. . . says a man who claims to suffer from it and yet appears to know nothing about it.

However, on hearing the news that Gary McKinnon could be sentenced to up to 70 years in a US jail for embarrassing their incompetent Government Sys Admins, he does go on to gloat:
Fantastic news, it's about ****** time. The irony is that if he'd pleaded guilty in the first place, he would have received a token sentence and probably been out by now! But no, he tried to lie his way out of it by denying the charges. n00b.
So, perhaps poor Evangelion does genuinely lack inborn social skills, moral judgement and empathy and does have severe trouble with social situations ;)


Incidentally Evangelion sweetie, if you bother to check the facts you will discover that Gary McKinnon has never denied hacking into some 70 American Government systems, he just denies that it was malicious or that he caused damage costing $800,000.

The US Government had to assert that some sort of damage was caused in order to be able to request his extradition. The money involved was probably to do with having to pay to get their clearly incompetent and lazy Sys Admins given some basic training and conducting an audit to discover how many other people had been wandering contentedly about their super secret systems.


To the rest of you (who don't suffer Asperger's); you might like to read "The Cuckoo's Egg" by Clifford Stoll who was asked to resolve a 75 cents system usage accounting error at a California University way back in the '80s, only to discover that it was due to a team of German hackers who were accessing US Government computers and flogging secrets to the KGB. It took Stoll a very, very long time to get the FBI, CIA or NSA even vaguely interested. An excellent read!

American Government IT Security appears not to have learnt much since then and some rednecks may be a wee bit embarrassed and keen to have a lynching ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom