Are both cards set at 1.112 voltage? Try adding two notches of voltage to the 74.9% Asic card as technically that should be 1.175v instead of 1.112v. As you can see its right on the limit.
ASIC quality < 75% - 1.1750 V
ASIC quality < 80% - 1.1125 V
ASIC quality < 85% - 1.0500 V
ASIC quality < 90% - 1.0250 V
ASIC quality < 100% - 1.0250 V
Sorry to butt in half way through a conversation but do you have a ASIC quality list with volts from 60% up