US: The Expanse - ** Please use spoiler tags for reveals with TV show or books**

Associate
Joined
14 Jan 2014
Posts
1,610
Location
The Matrix
Came across this the other day and started watching last night. Can't believe it's been out since 2015 and I haven't come across it until now lol

Only 2 episodes in and always give a new show at least 5 episodes before I make my mind up but i'm not blown away so far.
 

v0n

v0n

Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
8,130
Location
The Great Lines Of Defence
Very slow burner. Once you get into it though, it's one of the best sci fi things in history of TV, although... it's always one inch from absolute greatness - you can't help but think if it got just a few $$ more during casting and production stage we would be watching Game of Thrones in space type of TV event...
 
Caporegime
Joined
17 Jul 2010
Posts
25,735
In fairness the budget for S1 of GoT was relatively small compared to season's two and three. They didn't expect the wild popularity of GoT when they first started it.
 
Permabanned
Joined
23 Apr 2014
Posts
23,553
Location
Hertfordshire
After waiting till I finished the last(published) book I carried on watching this. Deviates a bit from the book and some of the characters are not as strong as they should be however it just wouldn't fit in a 13 episode season I guess.

Overall its pretty good, even knowing whats going to happen. :)
 
Soldato
Joined
20 Dec 2004
Posts
15,841
Finally made it to the end of Season 1. The acting is execrable and the script is desperately cringe-inducing. There's an interesting storyline hiding under the dross but not good enough to make up for how bad the basics are.

Shame as I would like a decent sci-fi series to watch....but I'm not one of those people that just brushes over how crap something is just because it's an interesting genre.

Think I'll just read the books. Or re-read the Culture series again. Man if only someone would put the cash up for TV versions of Ian M Banks books as big budget miniseries instalments (with a decent cast)
 
Soldato
Joined
18 Oct 2002
Posts
9,297
Location
Pembrokeshire
There's an interesting storyline hiding under the dross but not good enough to make up for how bad the basics are.

It's not particularly polished is it :)

However, I don't mind seeing through the slightly naff bits to find the storyline. As the story progresses it does get better and the series is staying pretty well to the source which is always a good thing IMO.

Season 2 is better for sure. Has more land based scenes which I think adds a little gravity (see what I did there?) rather than nearly all in space.
 
Soldato
Joined
20 Dec 2004
Posts
15,841
S2 isn't on Netflix here yet, will give it a go when it arrives but not holding my breath in anticipation.

Just need to mix up the characters a bit (wet behinds the ears pretty boy lead guy *yawn*, Duke Nukem army guy *yawn*, feisty female tech *yawn*) and get some better actors involved. And some better script writers so the dialogue isn't so cliche.

The back story about the Earth/Mars/Belt, the politics and societal stuff is very good...and it's nice to finally see space ships on screen that obey the laws of physics.
 
Associate
Joined
2 Jul 2003
Posts
2,436
S2 isn't on Netflix here yet, will give it a go when it arrives but not holding my breath in anticipation.

Just need to mix up the characters a bit (wet behinds the ears pretty boy lead guy *yawn*, Duke Nukem army guy *yawn*, feisty female tech *yawn*) and get some better actors involved. And some better script writers so the dialogue isn't so cliche.

The back story about the Earth/Mars/Belt, the politics and societal stuff is very good...and it's nice to finally see space ships on screen that obey the laws of physics.

Hmm, little harsh. Lead character is meant to be a wet behind the ears pretty boy stereotype. It's his meddling, trying to do the right thing, that keeps making things go from bad to worse.
Duke Nukem character, Amos isn't your regular hard nut army guy. If anything he's one of the most interesting characters on the show (in the books too). A psychopath who wants to be nice but has absolutely no moral compass. So surrounds himself with people he thinks are decent.
Naomi in the show is a little grating and not sure actress that great. Maybe she improves in series 2? Her character has a pretty good arc in the books so hope she can pull it off. In the first season (especially the first 5 episodes) she just comes across as a *****.

Show and actors still finding it's feet. People can be a little too fickle these days. Star Trek tng wouldn't have lasted more than half a season if it came out today.
 
Associate
Joined
14 Jan 2014
Posts
1,610
Location
The Matrix
Cheers Guys,

Managed to get passed S1 and i'm near the end of S2.

Need to get passed the first few episodes to get into it for me, glad you guys persuaded me. :p

Once you see passed some dodgy acting and questionable dialect from 'The Belters' it's a great show and interesting story line, can't get enough! :D

Sign me up for S3 :cool:
 
Back
Top Bottom