Looks like 5 crank lengths on the newer models.
Last edited:
The Indoor Riding/ Zwift/ TrainerRoad etc. Thread
- Thread starter randomshenans
- Start date
Do you "need" the different crank lengths though?
I guess it depends on how much indoor riding you each might do, and i'll admit i'm not sensitive to small adjustments, but compromising at something like 165 would probably be fine for both of you.
Shes 5'2" with short legs for her height. I think 165 is about the absolute max she can handle and honestly, I don't think any of the bikes go much lower than that anyway. I don't know how much of a difference it makes going from 165 to 172.5 which is what it would be for me.
Associate
- Joined
- 21 Jun 2004
- Posts
- 1,673
I have the stages SB20 and it can do 165-175mm in 4 increments. I’m not sure how feasible it is to always be changing the pedals over though, i guess it would depend how often they were riding. I wonder if she or you would notice much difference if it was just at 170 or 165 and never moved. The pros use shorter cranks, so we all should……
I noticed you edited your post and added a cheapo Giant. <snip>
The Indoor Riding/ Zwift/ TrainerRoad etc. Thread
Pack dynamics 2.0 was even worse, 3.0 we using now is better but still has a lot of issues for sure. Especially on downhills in large packs at speed. 6.5 pulls would have taken us back across to front group for sure but every single person in the back of the split had someone in the front of...forums.overclockers.co.uk
Haha, riding a Giant alloy frame on a trainer is a rite of passage! Hell... I still am. Rode 2 others before it, but first on a Direct Drive was my Giant Defy 1 2015, cracked the frame 2021, warrantied with a Giant Contend SL1 (which has only been ridden outside 3-4 times and probably less than 50km total). according to Strava that's done over 13,500 km now. The Defy had done 22,600km but did spend the start of it's life outdoors/commuter/etc.Haha same here. Elite Direto and Giant Defy
Strange for her to be that low as generally 165 is 'standard' for smaller riders and anything below it quite bespoke/special. I mean at 5'2" she's not exactly small...! But in a similar vein you also at over 6 foot being on 170 is quite a short crank length for your height...
Probably 170 is the way to go. If she's not ridden that much to know how much she'll ride online, then she can probably ride 170 ok (as whatever she's riding will feel 'strange' for her), so cater for yourself who'll certainly benefit from the slightly bigger, than compromising yourself 'just in case' she rides. The ideal scenario is she is fine on 170 and rides it so much then wants a setup of her own... Then you can buy sizing specific!
So much of the current trend of fitter sizing riders down is to increase efficiency, reading between the lines that is trying to increase cadence for a given gear/speed as making the pedal stroke smoother at lower rpm doesn't have as big a change to the efficicency? Or is it more about the wider range of gears we're increasing riding on modern setups...? Interesting.
For me riding 172.5 all the way through until now... Medium/54cm frames at 5'7" (172cm) I'm towards the lower end of sizing, while also 'knowing' I've got short legs for my height, yet only now with the new bike did the fitter suggest 170mm is better suited for me. The same fitter ~4-5 years ago didn't identify it as beneficial/required for me (the same question had been asked about sizing down to 52cm frame but again no) and same for 2 other fits I've had before. Riding 172.5 on 2 bikes (winter/commuter/everyday & turbo) with 170 on my summer I can't say I can really tell much difference. I'm rocking less in the saddle (I have a leg imbalance) but I think the move from a 143mm wide saddle to a 155mm has had more impact to that than the crank length change. I guess much of it is conditioning, having ridden for so many years on 172.5 that is my 'normal', which will take changing other bikes to 170 and months/years of riding to make 170 'normal' - but I don't know then if 172.5 will 'feel' any different.
Last edited:
Did mywhoosh again today, didn't go so well..
Turned tablet on new update, downloaded and installed new app then downloaded all the maps, including two new ones.
Seeing as I'm new to mywhoosh thought I'd do a ramp test, loaded up found sensors and click on Belgium as I used that map last time for initial test, system crashed to desktop (android tablet).
Reloaded but it couldn't find sensor, so I switched them off and ten seconds later back on, sensors now found I tried to load Belgium back in, nope crashed to desktop.
This time I reboot tablet, still can't find sensors so turn them off and back on ten seconds later, boom ready to rock, this time I chose ramp test but California instead, all loads up fine and I'm going okay but not to sure on erg working (pedals and Garmin are showing increase), I get to about 160 watts and I'm happy erg is behaving, then just as I'm about go from 197 to 207 crash to desktop.
I load straight back in and sensors found with no need to switch off but have to just start a free ride, that crashes about eighteen minutes in, at which point I give up and just carry on keeping an eye on the Garmin.
Turned tablet on new update, downloaded and installed new app then downloaded all the maps, including two new ones.
Seeing as I'm new to mywhoosh thought I'd do a ramp test, loaded up found sensors and click on Belgium as I used that map last time for initial test, system crashed to desktop (android tablet).
Reloaded but it couldn't find sensor, so I switched them off and ten seconds later back on, sensors now found I tried to load Belgium back in, nope crashed to desktop.
This time I reboot tablet, still can't find sensors so turn them off and back on ten seconds later, boom ready to rock, this time I chose ramp test but California instead, all loads up fine and I'm going okay but not to sure on erg working (pedals and Garmin are showing increase), I get to about 160 watts and I'm happy erg is behaving, then just as I'm about go from 197 to 207 crash to desktop.
I load straight back in and sensors found with no need to switch off but have to just start a free ride, that crashes about eighteen minutes in, at which point I give up and just carry on keeping an eye on the Garmin.
Last edited:
Hmm, that was my problem with MyWoosh, it crashed about a mile in. I just left it. I can't use something unstable... it would annoy me too much if I rode for an hour then it lost it all. I guess I could run something alongside it to safeguard against that, but it's a pain in the bum then.
Yeah I've had a few issues with MyWhoosh. Is rather they dialed back the graphics as well and just concentrate on getting the underlying system rock solid.
Not sure what to try next, see which is the cheapest. I've actually done a few rides just watching a movie.
I record on my Garmin so crashes aren't the end of the world.
Not sure what to try next, see which is the cheapest. I've actually done a few rides just watching a movie.
I record on my Garmin so crashes aren't the end of the world.
Well today I went back on it, although I'd installed it on my pixel 6 this time, it loaded up all good, found all sensors and I managed a one and half hour base ride.
The only issue I think I had was low wattage zones I wasn't sure erg was working, I was on 46/24 so dropped to small front 33/24 and it seemed to work ok.
There is a setting to take ready at one second or three second intervals, currently set at three so will try one and see if that makes any difference.
The only issue I think I had was low wattage zones I wasn't sure erg was working, I was on 46/24 so dropped to small front 33/24 and it seemed to work ok.
There is a setting to take ready at one second or three second intervals, currently set at three so will try one and see if that makes any difference.
It still takes the readings as often but averages over 3s so it's not jumping around all over the place. I like 3s so I can easily see the power is set correct.
I still do the Zwift free milage. It's annoying how much better Zwift is.
Heard on the Wild Ones podcast that Mywhoosh are allowing people to migrate levels/miles from Zwift to their platform.
Absolute genius level PR for them as i imagine it's something which would hold a lot of people back
Absolute genius level PR for them as i imagine it's something which would hold a lot of people back
I dunno, thats stealing customers 101. Make it as easy and seamless as possible for people to migrate from their current provider to you. I'm not that bothered by my level on Zwift. I am really stubborn about my ascent to get that damn tron bike though!
Yeah it's really clever, in the grand scheme of things it makes no difference to anyone. Think I'm 35 on zwift and currently 10 on whoosh, won't be bothering myself but I can see why some would.
It seems to behave better on 1s rather than 3s, probably just in my head, my only issue with whoosh is connectivity and device requirements, zwift just seems to work
Yes I'm not a fan of MyWhoosh graphics runs like crap on my laptop, like 15fps.It seems to behave better on 1s rather than 3s, probably just in my head, my only issue with whoosh is connectivity and device requirements, zwift just seems to work
Seems to run fine on my pixel 6 but unfortunately i cant plug a monitor in as pixel doesn't usb c to hdmi, it should cast to a chromecast but i don't have one
You don't have a Chromecast?! How have you made it through the last 10 years without being given a free one?! You must be about the only person on the planetit should cast to a chromecast but i don't have one
I don't have one either. Why would i even want one.You don't have a Chromecast?! How have you made it through the last 10 years without being given a free one?! You must be about the only person on the planet
Aside the fact they are really handy, it's not about wanting one. Google don't care if you want one, they hand them out to anyone and everyone! I'm honestly amazed there are people on this forum that don't have one! I got to the point I had spares so I was decking out elderly relatives with them.
I guess if you live in Apple/iOS world... then you've got bigger problems to deal with.
Associate
- Joined
- 19 Nov 2021
- Posts
- 1,110
- Location
- Portsmouth
ah ha! All the work paid off... went for an mtb ride in the new forest with some friends, and last time we went I was pushing the bike up the hills and falling way back.
This time I overtook them up the first hill!!
but now I need to learn to pace myself, it was not pretty directly thereafter
This time I overtook them up the first hill!!
but now I need to learn to pace myself, it was not pretty directly thereafter