*** The official HTC One S thread ***

The ones with the trees and sky is a huge difference. Look at the bushes, you can't see the individual leaves properly on the HOS pictures but the S3 brings them right out.

My god you must have good eye sight to be able to see the detail of the leaves in those photos :o :p

I can see that the GS 3 looks sharper on the leaves, but I can't make any real detail out of them personally, need to see the full size image for that part really.

I think the 1S for that is more pleasing to look at though.

The biggest difference is in the leaves and the purple flowers photo, you can really see a big difference there between the 2.

This was @ 2130 last night - so fairly low light conditions.

Not sure if the S3 has had the camera update yet.

S2 - S3 - HOS

another pink example from the HOS:

snip

Hmm, hard to say as that is what stoosh's first set of photos looked like, so that could be the case......


But judging on those, the GS 2 looks quite blurry and a bit dull.

The GS 3 looks the sharpest and has captured more detail than both, but a bit washed out in terms of colours (probably more close to the real life colours though :p)

The 1S again to me looks the most pleasing due to the colours, also is clearer than the GS 2 but not as sharp as the GS 3 or as much detail captured in certain areas.

Nice garden :cool:


Hmm, that pink tint is weird! :confused:

I am most certain that I have yet to see that in any of my photos.

Does it happen in dark conditions with flash etc. or just low lit with no flash?

Your camera looks good there - but as you said a brighter condition may have helped.

I'm killing soo much of my time doing these tests - I normally never do this shizz - I blame you Nexus! :p

Yeah, it may have, will try again tomorrow and see how things turn out :)


Lol :D :D :D


:p







It is much appreciated though and I am sure not just by me :)

EDIT:

BTW just rebooted my phone and battery stats are still there :)
 
Last edited:
The problem with you saying it looks "more pleasing" is that that's all it means. It doesn't mean it's a better camera and in practice will work out to produce worse shots due to the fact that there's potential to correct/adjust the perceived downfalls in the S3s pictures whereas there isn't any way to create additional detail in post processing to bring the HOSs pictures up to par. I'd rather it capture the image with finer detail and more realistic/less vibrant hues that I can then ramp up later myself, than be stuck with less detail but instant vibrancy.
 
Last edited:
The problem with you saying it looks "more pleasing" is that that's all it means. It doesn't mean it's a better camera and in practice will work out to produce worse shots due to the fact that there's potential to correct/adjust the perceived downfalls in the S3s pictures whereas there isn't any way to create additional detail in post processing to bring the HOSs pictures up to par. I'd rather it capture the image with finer detail and more realistic/less vibrant hues that I can then ramp up later myself, than be stuck with less detail but instant vibrancy.

I didn't say it was a better camera at all :confused:


I said the photos look better/more pleasing, that doesn't mean that the camera is automatically better...........

Also I think the majority of people would prefer the 1S photo overall due to the vibrant colours, just like all the people here who prefer AMOLED screens to LCD screens for that exact same reason, vibrant colours despite not being as sharp looking.

Both are good cameras in their own way as has been shown in this thread. The GS 3 for overall quality is better (apart from low lit shots from what I have seen so far and that is if you aren't keen on the vibrant photos of the 1s), I don't think anyone is going to deny that, however, the S brings great features to the table and the camera UI etc. is better than the GS 3 (granted this isn't related to the hardware but the software, but it all fits together and therefore is also part of the package regarding the camera and thus IMO brings the one series mobiles/S/X in direct competition with the GS 3).


And as you have also just pointed out there, it all comes down to personal preference in the end. You rather have the sharpness/finer detail and do the colour stuff yourself in photoshop or whatever, I would rather have a photo, which looks more "pleasing" to me overall that needs no work to be done to it in the first place.

Also, you never know as HTC may patch the camera so that the vibrancy of photos is reduced and increase the sharpness etc. just like Samsung did with the GS 3 and colours/sharpness etc.
 
Just ordered one of these on contract, looking forward to it, should arrive tomorrow!

Does anyone have any recomendations for a nice case for it under £10?

What sort of case?

Hard plastic case that covers only the sides?

If yes, then the nillkin super shield case (can only buy from ebay though)

The rock quicksand case (can only buy from ebay)

Case mate barely there (can get it from some places for about £13)


Or if you want pure protection, then the case mate tough, you can see my review of it below in the sig :) (although costs £20+)


If you want something that is slim and light but covers all sides then the TPU/diztronic gel cases are your best bet, they cost about £2-6 on the rainforest site or ebay, I think this one looks the best and isn't a gel type of material :D:

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=251047982451#ht_1830wt_1396
 
Last edited:
Also zefan, the one S is very capable of capturing a lot of detail and producing sharp photos, maybe not as much as the GS 3, but it is still damn good for a mobile:

http://i.imgur.com/oMwDh.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/6NzdT.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/AOfuh.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/Uyelv.jpg

These shots were taken from inside a bus on a dark cloudy day:

http://i.imgur.com/5NkPJ.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/sNIjO.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/HPEte.jpg

http://i.imgur.com/Ox28K.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/UnzhN.jpg

Taken from inside a bus as well:

http://i.imgur.com/yxphv.jpg

EDIT:

And all the above were taken with default/auto settings, so if I manually adjusted the settings, they could have looked even better.

EDIT:

And another photo to try and show the detail that is captured and sharpness (excuse the dead hedge and over grown ivy etc. :o :p):

http://i.imgur.com/NzBw3.jpg
 
Last edited:
I just find it to be more polished overall with certain UI areas and features. It also has a quick share feature, which will share the web page via gmail, sms app etc. straight away (copies the web address and opens the text/gmail app and pastes it in the box automatically), the quick controls fit in the page no matter where you place your finger where as with ICS + they just go off the screen when you touch near the bottom or top of the screen. I also find it to be a bit quicker at loading and rendering web pages and just more features overall regarding the quick ics controls. Should give it a try, I think you will prefer it as well :)

I found after a day of Opera I was drifting back to ICS+. Generally just found ICS+ that little bit faster than Opera. Having to hit 'back' twice when zoomed in to actually go back was getting tedious.

So read your post mentioning Quick ICS and gave it a try. Pretty much find all you mention above and now bought the donate version. It's less than a £ so not what you would call expensive. Had to broaden the area either side of screen receptive to triggering the quick controls as it wasn't responding. There's not a lot between the two ICS browsers and think Quick ICS wins by a short head :p

Nexus, I know there may be an update coming to remove the 3 dot menu waste of screen real-estate but having rooted and flashed a rom that gets rid of it I can say it a great improvement. Highly recommend :D

Phone feels a little faster with the Trickdroid ROM and probably down to clearing the bloatware. Perhaps better memory management too? Battery life may be slightly better but hard to quantify really. One issue I have is that I lose mobile network connection and then reconnects with an 'R' above the signal strength bars. I presume this is roaming and onto what network from Three, I dunno. Data speeds drop down to unusable. This also seems to drag the battery down pretty quickly? I'm sure this and mobile reception in general seems slightly worse with the Trickdroid ROM. Not a frequent issue so we'll see how that goes.

No regrets ... though warranty may be an issue now :( Unlocking bootloader then rooting is pretty straight forward as is flashing the Trickdroid (i my case) rom. After that flash the boot.ini and you are good to go. Final step is flashing the tweaks package. Sounds a complicated going on but read up on the job first and it should not be a prob.
 
The problem with you saying it looks "more pleasing" is that that's all it means. It doesn't mean it's a better camera and in practice will work out to produce worse shots due to the fact that there's potential to correct/adjust the perceived downfalls in the S3s pictures whereas there isn't any way to create additional detail in post processing to bring the HOSs pictures up to par. I'd rather it capture the image with finer detail and more realistic/less vibrant hues that I can then ramp up later myself, than be stuck with less detail but instant vibrancy.

I do find my One S camera on the whole quite good but can struggle with white balance when reds and greens dominate in the picture. Mine over-saturates reds and greens too. Plainly I prefer to use my Nikon but don't have it with me everywhere I go and no way will it go in my pocket :rolleyes: As Nexus says, for what the phone camera is used for by the majority of people then the saturated photo will appeal and the loss of detail won't be noticed.
 
The problem with you saying it looks "more pleasing" is that that's all it means. It doesn't mean it's a better camera and in practice will work out to produce worse shots due to the fact that there's potential to correct/adjust the perceived downfalls in the S3s pictures whereas there isn't any way to create additional detail in post processing to bring the HOSs pictures up to par. I'd rather it capture the image with finer detail and more realistic/less vibrant hues that I can then ramp up later myself, than be stuck with less detail but instant vibrancy.

At the end of the day it's a phone. If you were that bothered about taking amazing photos you wouldn't be using a phone you'd have a dslr. So for me if it looks better it looks better, technicalities that aren't really big changes are irrelevant. Not to mention the costs of the phones involved, hardly surprising the more expensive one comes out on top even if it is marginal in most cases
 
Really interested in this phone and a quick search of this thread shows it hasn't been asked yet... Can this phone run games like GTA III, Dead Space and Max Payne? Oh and can apps be installed into the 'storage' part of the memory? You know, like "Move to SD Card" on my wildfire...
 
Really interested in this phone and a quick search of this thread shows it hasn't been asked yet... Can this phone run games like GTA III, Dead Space and Max Payne? Oh and can apps be installed into the 'storage' part of the memory? You know, like "Move to SD Card" on my wildfire...

Yes, yes, yes, yes and more yes.

It blows the Wildfire out of the water, and then proceeds to nuke it from orbit. :p
 
Haha yeah I know the S could eat my wildfail for breakfast, everyday for the entirety of my contract :P Will it still run the big 3D games in a year and a half's time? Or if I want that kind of future proofing, would I need to get the One X or the SIII? Are there many apps that would not be able to be "Move to Storage" 'd? I am a bit worried about the 2GB/10GB limit on the memory!
 
Haha yeah I know the S could eat my wildfail for breakfast, everyday for the entirety of my contract :P Will it still run the big 3D games in a year and a half's time? Or if I want that kind of future proofing, would I need to get the One X or the SIII? Are there many apps that would not be able to be "Move to Storage" 'd? I am a bit worried about the 2GB/10GB limit on the memory!

It's as future proof as either of those phones really, aside from storage as you say.

Ultimately, if it's a similar sort of price, the S3 would be the better option all round. I can go into more detail but it should be obvious as to why.
 
I found after a day of Opera I was drifting back to ICS+. Generally just found ICS+ that little bit faster than Opera. Having to hit 'back' twice when zoomed in to actually go back was getting tedious.

So read your post mentioning Quick ICS and gave it a try. Pretty much find all you mention above and now bought the donate version. It's less than a £ so not what you would call expensive. Had to broaden the area either side of screen receptive to triggering the quick controls as it wasn't responding. There's not a lot between the two ICS browsers and think Quick ICS wins by a short head :p

Yeah, it only just beats it by a bit IMO as well, it is just more pleasant to use overall, which is the main thing, it makes ICS+ feel like it is in beta stages still :p

Have also noticed that too sometimes with the quick ics controls, can be a bit annoying but all the other stuff makes up for it :)

Nexus, I know there may be an update coming to remove the 3 dot menu waste of screen real-estate but having rooted and flashed a rom that gets rid of it I can say it a great improvement. Highly recommend :D

Don't tempt me!!!!! :p

I can wait a little bit longer! (I hope :p)

Phone feels a little faster with the Trickdroid ROM and probably down to clearing the bloatware. Perhaps better memory management too? Battery life may be slightly better but hard to quantify really. One issue I have is that I lose mobile network connection and then reconnects with an 'R' above the signal strength bars. I presume this is roaming and onto what network from Three, I dunno. Data speeds drop down to unusable. This also seems to drag the battery down pretty quickly? I'm sure this and mobile reception in general seems slightly worse with the Trickdroid ROM. Not a frequent issue so we'll see how that goes.

Yeah, probably some tweaks to the software to make it a bit quicker and also due to removal of apps that can't be removed on stock etc. thus better memory management and yup I think trickdroid has a custom memory tweak built in (that is also used for the X IIRC).

Spot on! If you have a weak signal, or/and where your mobile is struggling to hold a signal then that will consume a fair bit of battery, particularly if it is with the mobile data connection.

Have you tried just enabling GSM only mode instead WCDMA/GSM, I find that my single was more consistent and stronger when I selected GSM only mode even when wifi is enabled. Kona said it also improved his voice reception.

No regrets ... though warranty may be an issue now :( Unlocking bootloader then rooting is pretty straight forward as is flashing the Trickdroid (i my case) rom. After that flash the boot.ini and you are good to go. Final step is flashing the tweaks package. Sounds a complicated going on but read up on the job first and it should not be a prob.

I am also concerned about loosing my warranty :( As knowing my luck something will go wrong and I won't be able to get into the recovery etc. :( :p

Yeah, will have to read the guides over and over again to get into the swing of things :p :o Did the exact same with my spica, must have read all the guides about 100 times before I actually did anything (rooted and flashed a custom after about 3-4 months of owning it).

Thanks :)

At the end of the day it's a phone. If you were that bothered about taking amazing photos you wouldn't be using a phone you'd have a dslr. So for me if it looks better it looks better, technicalities that aren't really big changes are irrelevant. Not to mention the costs of the phones involved, hardly surprising the more expensive one comes out on top even if it is marginal in most cases

+1 well said :)

It blows the Wildfire out of the water, and then proceeds to nuke it from orbit. :p

:D

Haha yeah I know the S could eat my wildfail for breakfast, everyday for the entirety of my contract :P Will it still run the big 3D games in a year and a half's time? Or if I want that kind of future proofing, would I need to get the One X or the SIII? Are there many apps that would not be able to be "Move to Storage" 'd? I am a bit worried about the 2GB/10GB limit on the memory!

Shouldn't have any problem at all as it is in the same league as the X/GS 3 for performance (the X has a slightly better GPU, the GS 3 GPU destroys both) but the S has the better processor overall (just edges the GS 3 CPU).

As for storage, yes some apps won't allow you to move them to SD storage i.e. widget apps.

As for the limited storage for both, I personally have no problems with it and 2GB is more than enough for me, however, if you plan on putting a load of games on and game files e.g. max payne 3 along with loads of music, tv episodes etc. then storage would be a problem.

For me:

Over 600 photos (including 1080P videos and slow motion videos etc.), icons, wallpapers and game emulator ROMs for SEGA and N64 with just over 65 apps installed (about 5 games) this is what I have left:

T4CDH.png

If you think that storage will be a problem, then the GS 3 is the phone to get (of course that is if you are willing to pay the extra)
 
Last edited:
The images on both the One S and S3 that are posted look very very blurry.

How is everyone resizing their images? Is this a conspiracy?

Take a look at this, resized in Photoshop and Windows image preview next to it. If you are just print screening the image and sticking it in paint maybe thats part of the problem? I'm not sure, but my shots look very sharp.

Look at the wall detail. It was a very bright day so not sure if that helps.

test.jpg



Pictures from the One S, 25% and 50%

civicbig.jpg


civicbig2.jpg
 
Last edited:
but the S has the better processor overall (just edges the GS 3 CPU).

What??

Nexus18's benchmark in quadrant (from earlier in the thread)- CPU score of 8605

url]


My GS3 benchmark - CPU score of 13149

Screenshot_2012-06-20-11-57-20.png


Just going from the CPU score, it would seem the GS3 CPU is ~50% better no?
 
Hmm, hard to say as that is what stoosh's first set of photos looked like, so that could be the case......


But judging on those, the GS 2 looks quite blurry and a bit dull.

The GS 3 looks the sharpest and has captured more detail than both, but a bit washed out in terms of colours (probably more close to the real life colours though :p)

The 1S again to me looks the most pleasing due to the colours, also is clearer than the GS 2 but not as sharp as the GS 3 or as much detail captured in certain areas.

Nice garden :cool:

Cheers.

Yeah the S2 really struggled to focus in the low light garden shot - I did try to focus but it wasn't having it - didn't spend too long as I wanted to make it a fair test of point and shoot.

S3 looks nice and sharp and detailed - but the exposure seems too high and it's lack a lot of contrast there - makes it look too daytime.

HOS - overall good - but way too saturated and lacking a bit of sharpness - the Hos has a saturation adjuster in the setting so may drop it down 1 level to see how they come out - may just cure it.

Hmm, that pink tint is weird! :confused:

I am most certain that I have yet to see that in any of my photos.

Does it happen in dark conditions with flash etc. or just low lit with no flash?

I have no idea why the pink happens - never happened it any of bright garden tests - I will keep an eye on it to see where it stems from. :)


It is much appreciated though and I am sure not just by me :)

No worries :)

EDIT:

BTW just rebooted my phone and battery stats are still there :)

Nice - I think when I changed sim the battery stats reset - but a quick reboot and they stay.


The images on both the One S and S3 that are posted look very very blurry.

How is everyone resizing their images? Is this a conspiracy?

Take a look at this, resized in Photoshop and Windows image preview next to it. If you are just print screening the image and sticking it in paint maybe thats part of the problem? I'm not sure, but my shots look very sharp.

Look at the wall detail. It was a very bright day so not sure if that helps.

My shots recently have been low light test that why they aren't that sharp - no print screening and paint here.
 
Back
Top Bottom