***The X-Factor Thread - ALL X-Factor Related Stuff In Here***

He always does this performing, look at his other live performances, he has very good control of his voice.

Listen at the start of the song, the first verse end of each line it fades away dramatically, this wouldn't be the case if it was a backing track to that extent.

He has every right to call you idiots, because to be honest you are.

He does this mic technique every single performance, and he hardly mimes every single performance, learn to listen more to the words and how certain letters sound, such a "t" and "s" etc.

No he doesn't use that mic technique all the time.
This is him 100% live and his mic is never more than 3" from his mouth.
A mic hasn't been invented that could reproduce the X-Factor clip.


And another 100% live without your imaginary technique -

 
Last edited:
A response from somewhere (trying to find original source):

“In order to hear a vocalist properly, it is important that his/her voice “loudness” be properly balanced relative to the music. If not loud enough, we won’t hear what they’re singing and if too loud, the music will sound “thin” Although it may seem simple to adjust the singer’s volume to match the music, it is not because some singers sing with wide “dynamic range” (it’s the difference between their loudest voice and their softest voice) and depending on the type of music they sing along, their softest voice may be totally “buried” under the music. The “busiest” the music is, the harder it gets (i.e. music having many instruments playing together will burry soft voice passage more than if only a single guitar is playing) There’s a whole science about this phenomena (psychoacoustics)

They’re basically two ways to fix this dynamic range issue: 1-vocal technique 2-compressors/limiters (They can also be combined together if desired)

– The standard technique to produce consistent volume into a microphone is for the singer to back off from the mic when singing loudly and get closer to the mic when singing softly. This technique is mostly important when singing into sound systems that don’t uses compressor/limiters, such as in small live clubs. Otherwise,good singers (such as Bublé) will overload the sound system (produce distortion) when singing loudly. The sound engineer could also lower the mic volume to prevent overload but then the soft passages would be buried under the music

However, ALL professional sound systems used in TV/Recording studios (including XFactor’s) use comp/limiters and they allow singers not to worry too much about their microphone technique as they will prevent any sound overloads (even if they would scream their hearts out directly into the mics) What these comp/limiters also do is allow picking up sounds that are relatively very far from the singer (like when Bublé moves away from the mic) and make them sound almost as loud as if the singer was singing up-close.

What comp/limiters cannot do is to compensate for frequency response changes resulting from microphone position relative to the vocalist (typically, the more closer/in-line with the mic the singer is, the more “bassy” and “brighter” it will sound. The further away/off-axis it is the more “midrange” it will sound.

What tells me Bublé was singing live is anytime he turns is head away from the mic (such as when he shouts “woaaa”) If you hear closely, you will hear his voice loose “brightness” (or if you prefer “treble”, “highs”) and that is definite side-effect of singing off-axis to a directional mic.”
 
Bublé isn't miming, he always does that. Some songs he doesn't use a mic because his voice is so powerful. I guess you've not seen him live before.
 
I dont know what you lot are listening to, but it doesnt sound note perfect to me

You're right. It isn't note perfect, but it is pretty damn close to what he could achieve in a recording studio, with multiple attempts at singing different parts of the song.

When someone sings live, the imperfections scream at you. But it is those imperfections which give the performance the character and differentiate a live performance from a perfected, studio recorded version of the song/track.

What really gets me, is not that he mimed, but the fact that he had the gall to call anybody who suggested that he was miming to pre-recorded vocals, stupid.

You will notice that when the xfactor contestants sing, the fact that they are singing live, is very obvious. This was not the case with M.Buble.
 
Harry Connick Jr > Mickey Bubbles

yeh I think he was live, nah I don't think he's anything special, all the women who gush over him wouldn't look at him twice if he was stacking shelves at Aldi
 
Well he's done it on both occasions I've seen him live.

I'm 100% positive that I could link to all his live performances on You Tube and we won't see him holding his mic 2 foot away and hearing the same volume coming out.
I reckon he will be holding it about 3" away (because that is his style) and then move it away when he goes louder (like all pro singers do).
If you can link to a 100% live performance where he uses the X-Factor technique then I'll be quiet.
Compressors/Limiters work very well but not with the style he used on X-factor.
 
I cant tell if its the Youtube video out of sync, but its deffo out of sync. Also there were hardly any close up camera shots.

OMG he is sooooo sexy in the vid with Stacey though :O

BB x
 
Just watched the X Factor performance of Buble and I'm not so sure he's miming. You can clearly hear at 1:18 as he moves the mic away, his voice trails off and when he moves the mic back very close to his mouth at 1:21, the sound of his vocal really changes again - and this is easy to hear if you have decent speakers/headphones. The mic does seem to get quite far away at some points though. I've just watched the Cry Me A River vid as well and it's very similar there too.
 
One fact which has been proved time and time again is that this guy can sing live, better than most. Numerous performances have shown this, so to me, even if he did mine it's not worth all this discussion.
 
Buble is the man, however i did (like a few have mentioned already) find it weird how he could move the mic and still control the same volume in his voice. Got skills.
 
well not sure if bon jovi was miming, but his guitarist wasnt playing, after loading up the show on the pc, and watching, when they zoom on his hands during solo, he aint even doin the part that is playing! lol
 
Back
Top Bottom