Ukraine Invasion - Please do not post videos showing attacks/similar

Status
Not open for further replies.
Russia isn't at the level of surveillance, etc. of China, neither do people tend to disappear in the same way as can happen in China, though freedoms are increasingly disappearing.
Does dozens of people falling out top floor windows not count as disappearing?
 
Wonder what actually happened to the Challenger 1s, they were our gulf war tanks I believe
More than a match for the majority of the russian tanks being fielded

The Challenger I left service in 2001, I doubt we have them around in a condition worth sending.

10 isn't that many and has lots of opportunity for Russia propaganda

No, it isn't. But the point is to encourage other countries to send tanks, in particular Scholz has made clear that Germany won't send tanks unless other allies choose to do so, and that means other countries with Leopard IIs can't send theirs either. These Challengers won't make all that much difference on their own, but if they get other allies to start sending tanks that could have a massive effect.
 
Wonder what actually happened to the Challenger 1s, they were our gulf war tanks I believe
More than a match for the majority of the russian tanks being fielded

Most of our old tanks were either entirely sold off i.e. to Jordan, or entirely scrapped.

I don't believe we have anything of any quantity sitting in storage aside from some Challenger 2s.

EDIT: Same with most of our stuff unfortunately - we have very little in the way of older stuff sitting in reserve.

EDIT2: Personally I think we should be looking to supply Ukraine with an upgraded version of the Alvis CVR(T) - it has several advantages or potential advantages for use in Ukraine including low ground pressure which should be of benefit with the terrain and relatively mobile - which suits a lot of the way Ukraine is fighting - though it would really need to find a way to get both ultra low ground pressure with increased armour to protect at least against 30mm cannon fire.
 
Last edited:
Most of our old tanks were either entirely sold off i.e. to Jordan, or entirely scrapped.

I don't believe we have anything of any quantity sitting in storage aside from some Challenger 2s.

EDIT: Same with most of our stuff unfortunately - we have very little in the way of older stuff sitting in reserve.

Yeah I suspected they would be basically gone. I know Jordan took them upgraded (new turrets I think)

I think this conflict may well cause some changes in thought process. Its not like we have massive quantities of tanks in the first place, or well in reality most equipment.
If your potentially going to supply some other country with equipment they don't necessarily need the latest version even if your willing to give it.
 
Is Russia still classed as a democracy? Chinas population seem to have it freer.
Russia has some semblance of a democracy back in the early 90's after the collapse of Communism in the country. Infact at that point you could argue Russia was the most capitalistic country in the world and what developed was some odd hybrid of capitalism and anarchy. The last election that was close to honest was 1999 which Putin won on the back of him 'dealing' with rebel Chechens, after Putin got his grubby mits on power he's done everything he can to make he holds onto it for as long as possible. Once all his rivals had been dealt with and there was no more credible opposition (with the only real opposition that's allowed to exist being the remnants of the old Communist party which more often then not supports Putin's more egregious actions) he started chipping away at people's freedoms which started back in 2011/2012 when he made protesting all but imposable and has just got more and more repressive since to the point where you can get arrested for just criticising government policy.
 
Nice to see some real British Beef going to Ukraine,such a shame it's only 10. That's hardly enough to defend a small town with but it would be good too them go up against the very army they were designed to fight even if its only a small batch.
 
Nice to see some real British Beef going to Ukraine,such a shame it's only 10. That's hardly enough to defend a small town with but it would be good too them go up against the very army they were designed to fight even if its only a small batch.
I don't know if I like that. Challenger 2's are something we have precious few of and upgrading even less to the new Challenger 3. Then there is the problem of supply as we really are the only ones that can supply the equipment and ammunition for the tanks to keep them going.

I do think the leopard 2 tanks or Abrams would be a much better solution as more people can help with supplying the spares and ammunition.
 
We'll hope for Challengers and end up sending Scorpions :rolleyes:
The Ukrainians already received some Spartan AFVs and are very happy with them. Fast and quiet compared to anything Russian, so ideal for the recognisance work they were designed for.

 
I don't know if I like that. Challenger 2's are something we have precious few of and upgrading even less to the new Challenger 3. Then there is the problem of supply as we really are the only ones that can supply the equipment and ammunition for the tanks to keep them going.

I do think the leopard 2 tanks or Abrams would be a much better solution as more people can help with supplying the spares and ammunition.

Leopard 2 would be much more ideal really - they are a bit lighter which is suited better to the situation, easier to source ammo for, etc. in theory maintenance should be closer to hand.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom