Amnesia and Metro 2033
Ultra scary? Amnesia
Scary in places? Metro
Great graphics? Both
i think thats doom 3 your thinking of with the little babythings with wings.
let her play the first ten minutes of doom 3 in a dark room, she will jump out of her chair - guaranteed.
as for graphics Crysis jungle part still gets top vote
and then you get a big gun and the horror goes out the window. Doom 3 is not a scary game in the slightest.
Now the Amnesia demo that i just dl'd...
Is a great game. For me it's sitting just below SS2, and waaaay above BioShock.
System Shock 2
Dead Space
.....
.....
.....
.....
(chasm)
.....
BioShock.
Sorry I just can't resist having a snipe at BioShock; one of my more anticipated games that turned out to be a total dud.