Maybe I have red tinted glasses but I think Cesc is truly brilliant and will be better than Xavi, sometimes it's hard to believe he's only 22, he's nearly the complete player already
I personally think he's better than Xavi, based on the fact that it was always him coming on that turned Spain from a side not conceding, to a side freescoring and utterly dominating the other side, there was a very obvious difference between Spain with, and without Fabregas.
As for inconsistant, he's not, a large portion of his game is assists, if the guys infront aren't finishing, people deem you've had a bad game, if they finish every chance you create for them people decide you had a great game, even if you make the same passes in both games.
I also don't know how people ignore it but consistantly since Gilberto/Flamini left he's dropped far deeper far more often than he used to helping out defensively a heck of a lot every game.
Not playing for Barca, in a what I think is easier to score in league, I don't think he'll ever seem quite as effective.
Obertan might have missed a sitter, but his interplay was otherwise much much better than Nani's, playing 1-2's to and passing/moving in triangles well to get past people. Rooney, I just still think looks awful as an out and out striker that team needs a Owen who spends his entire time on the pitch moving around the CB's making them nervous and making mistakes. Also still think Utd need Neville or a real replacement as Valencia just doesn't get those chances to move/pass/overlap like Obertan had in the final minutes with Evra. Valencia need's a pacey fullback who actually knows how to attack, pass and play the wing properly. Neville can still do that and his crossing is still incredibly good. Rafael is to crap defensively, haven't seen a game he doesn't constantly hack people down as he desparately tries to get back.
The first Liverpool red was indeed a red, it wasn't for the contact it was the intent of the jumping in with studs showing both feet off the ground.
He's lucky, he had zero control of himself and if Dempsey had planted his foot in Degans path, his ankle could be broken, its a dangerous tackle, flying in out of control with studs showing. IN all fairness those are frequently given as yellows, but they quite often give out red's for those types of tackles even if the contact isn't made.