Soldato
Ghost in the Shell 5/10
I think I have a very uncertain relationship with the whole GitS franchise. After seeing the film I feel it kind of amplifies what I feel about the whole thing, anime inclusive although to a lesser extent as it's generally a better experience - Ghost in the Shell tries to be about the bigger picture of the human condition and what it means, but for one reason or another it never quite gets there. The film, despite trying to shoehorn in the anime checklist, doesn't feel very interesting and doesn't really explain it's world very well. I stuck through it, but I wouldn't recommend it to anyone unless they had 2 hours of time to waste.
Whilst I pretty much agree with everything you've written there, surely it's worth an extra point for Scarlett Johansson in a skin tight outfit though
I'd go for a 6/10