Dark Places
Based on the book of the same name by Gillian Flynn.
I read the book on dark nights sailing crossing the Atlantic last year. Typical Gillian Flynn murder mystery stuff, extremely dark and disturbing, with strong female leads, exciting twists and revelations. The book was fantastic. The film not so much.
It's always difficult when a book is adapted for the screen, but some pull it off. The Talented Mr Ripely for one. Dark Places not so much. Firstly the casting is completely wrong not just the lead, but throughout. Charlize Theron was totally the wrong person to play Libby Day. In the book Libby is more of a mess Wynona Rider style in Reality Bites. Theron, just comes across as angry and unlikeable.
It's a similar story with most of the characters. No background. No real motives, just maybe a sentence thrown in, that is supposed to be their reason for acting in a certain way.
Unlike some of her other work. Flynn didn't write the screenplay for this, and it shows. The film misses all the subtleties of the book, and offers little room for depth or development. Even at 1:50 long it is rushed. I found there no reason at all to like or care for any of the characters, and the whole thing seemed disjointed.
'Gone Girl' does a better job as adaptation of a Flynn novel. Though Affleck is wooden in that. The only adaptation so far that has completely captured the atmosphere of a Flynn novel is 'Sharp Objects,' and that was mini-series. Really worth watching if you like dark shows.
As highly as I rate the book (its a solid 8 or 9/10), the film more a 6/10.