Star Trek: First Contact - 7/10
Nnnggghhh...
Okay. So much of this film is great. The cast are all right on their game, including the guests - James Cromwell wasn't a good physical match for the Cochrane seen in TOS but as the Gene analogue that this story makes him into he was pitch perfect. Alfre Woodard, also brilliant.
And then we get to Alice Krige. And she too was fantastic...but she was playing a character whose very existence makes the Borg so much less. When the Borg were introduced in TNG's "Q Who" they were genuinely quite scary - they didn't give one half of a solitary **** about you, they just wanted your technology if it had something to offer and if you got between it and them then they simply would not stop until that state of affairs was rectified. But TV execs need a bad guy to spout threats, so then they gain a voice with which to demand you surrender. And then by "The Best Of Both Worlds" they want to turn you into one of them, so now they're space vampires but at least still with the collective consciousness.
But that falls apart here. Because now the Borg aren't a collective consciousness - they're puppets dancing to a tune whistled by one consciousness, the Borg Queen. Which might be more cinematic and definitely gives us a specific villain to root against, but to me it's so much less interesting.
It's a shame, because there's lots to like about this outing. Visually it's a huuuuuge upgrade on Generations in nearly all respects. The new-for-this-film Enterprise-E is striking, clearly still in the same 'navy' as the previous Enterprises but at the same time evolving starship design in ways that make sense for the Dominion War era. The themes going on are all very worthy, between Picard's quest for revenge, Data's continuing quest to become more human, the Borg Queen's quest for domination and humanity's quest to drag themselves from the ashes of Global Political Mess Up™ part three and Boldly Go Where No-one Has Gone Before.
I just wish it was still the implacable, remorseless Borg from the first half of "Q Who" and not what they became - a bunch of henchmen following the lead of an insane woman with a bunch of cables in the back of her head. At least we can be glad that they weren't as nerfed here as they became during Voyager, the villain decay there was dismaying to say the least...
It's still the best of the Next Gen films by some way - both Generations and Insurrection have issues, and Nemesis flat out sucks. But it's no Wrath of Khan or Undiscovered Country.