Caporegime
- Joined
- 7 Apr 2008
- Posts
- 25,176
- Location
- Lorville - Hurston
Many people i know in real life hated it
Poll: Winter Is Coming - HBO's A Game of Thrones [READ WARNING]
- Thread starter Hostile_18
- Start date
i don't know anyone in real life that liked it.
Caporegime
- Joined
- 7 Apr 2008
- Posts
- 25,176
- Location
- Lorville - Hurston
Yup. One thing we can use to back our claims that it was a poor series is if you look at imdb etc and see how majority did not rate it
Soldato
- Joined
- 13 Jun 2011
- Posts
- 6,053
But @Mr Jack said its a pointless discussion. How dare any of you continue to voice your opinions!
This made me chuckle - a post from just over 10 years ago on page 1:
10 years on and there are still 2 books left for him to write
10 years on and there are still 2 books left for him to write
All the hate of the last season... I dunno. I kind of feel that people ‘pseudo-intellectualised’ their enjoyment of the earlier seasons and threw their toys out the pram when the show picked up the pace which necessarily required a bit of dumbing down. People just couldn’t reasonably suspend disbelief. There were valid criticisms to be had but I did think the hate was a bit ‘lol’. I really enjoyed it. Perhaps, in part, because I wanted to?
Go in looking for a bad time... you’re going to have a bad time.
I laughed heartily at the resolution of Bran’s arc though. I really feel that the under development of Bran was the biggest failing of the show.
Go in looking for a bad time... you’re going to have a bad time.
I laughed heartily at the resolution of Bran’s arc though. I really feel that the under development of Bran was the biggest failing of the show.
Comments like this make me laugh. Clearly you know better than Netflix (and Amazon and Disney who were both bidding for them)
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/live-feed/game-thrones-creators-close-200m-netflix-deal-1230119And with that I'm backing out of this thread because it's largely pointless now! Assuming it only got bumped because people were whinging about the awards?
Permabanned
- Joined
- 23 Apr 2014
- Posts
- 23,552
- Location
- Hertfordshire
This made me chuckle - a post from just over 10 years ago on page 1:
10 years on and there are still 2 books left for him to write
Yeah, hes not gonna bother. Will milk all the other stuff before he croaks I expect and who can blame him, probably make far more from all the associated guff than the books.
probably best you do, you've obviously got no sensible side of an argument. doesn't matter who's bidding for what, doesn't alter that last season was the biggest pile of garbage in the last decade. if Netflix et al want to hoy their money at that sort of quality, that's up to them, it doesn't magically make the last season's plotting suddenly clever and sensible, does it?Comments like this make me laugh. Clearly you know better than Netflix (and Amazon and Disney who were both bidding for them)
And with that I'm backing out of this thread because it's largely pointless now! Assuming it only got bumped because people were whinging about the awards?
I'm not arguing about season 8, sorry. I'm just curious as to why you think they shouldn't be in a job. An opinion that directly contradicts 3 of the biggest entertainment companies in the world who have been clambering to employ them.
You say I've got no "sensible argument" yet you're spouting nonsense like the above, together with "biggest pile of garbage in the last decade". Exaggeration much? No?
Because if I put as little effort into my job as they did into the end of the series I'd be fired. Hollywood and the like is a boys club, it's about who you know and money, whether what you create is **** or not doesn't matter as long as the money flows in, and GoT was always going to make money.
Having watched the show through 3 times (once all before season 6 and then again leading up to the release of the seasons), I disagree. The trade off for the ‘dumbing down’ (and by this I really mean allowing for ‘not laboriously explaining anything and requiring minor disbelief’) was ‘substantially advancing the plot’. About time, really. Half of the enjoyment of the show was the anticipation of the epic things to be. You can only ride on anticipation for so long and had it continued at its then current pace I think viewers would have been frustrated. I would have been, anyway. I don’t think any alternative resolution would have made the show substantially more enjoyable to me.
Of course, by resolution I mean things regarding the story arc in general. I’m not a person to get upset over whether there is adequate cloud cover to see some ships from a dragon.
This is coming from someone that tend not to enjoy TV shows precisely because they don’t conclude. I have labelled this previously as ‘the perpetual carrot’. TV shows that have storylines dragged out as long as people will watch them disinterest me. But, people that are more willing to spend time watching TV may have a different view.
So what you're saying is that Hollywood is corrupt but they're clearly good at their jobs, as the evidence shows? Because if you'd like ot complain about season 8 then honestly, go nuts. Just bear in mind that's your opinion on a creative piece of TV drama. If you want to argue that they're no good at their jobs and "should be fired" then I'm sorry but the evidence points to the contrary. I'm just making sure we're on the same page here...
Exactly. It's like the ending of Lost. I'd say a good 75% of that series was anticipation so when it eventually wrapped up, you lost that 75% of excitement (for want of a better word). It's just what can happen in series like that.
I was going to post something similar. It's all opinion. It's funny how the haters seem genuinely upset that some could enjoy it still. Sure, I'll agree it wasn't as good as other seasons, but I still enjoyed it.
It's Game of Thrones, I could have written Season 8 and it would have made just as much, doesn't mean I'm a good writer or showrunner. They established the shows fanbase by being very good at adapting the books. When those ran out their was a noticeable steady decline in quality but the goodwill remained as the show itself was still pretty good. That goodwill ran out when it became obvious they didn't care anymore and it became a poorly written, inconsistent mess with 10 years of character development going out the window, main characters becoming glorified extras and **** making no sense all just for that big 'Oh ****!' moment. No one I know liked season 8 and the vast majority of the internet didn't like season 8, you liking season 8 puts you in the minority from what I can tell. When liking season 8 puts you in the minority, they've done a **** poor job of producing it.
You're more than welcome to enjoy it, I enjoy the Star Wars prequels, doesn't mean they're not **** films.
Again. Opinion.
Again, when the general opinion on something is that it's bad, it is indeed bad. Otherwise literally nothing can generally be considered good or bad because "That's just your opinion, maaaaaaaaaan"
.It IS all opinion, but some of the criticisms at GOT series 8 and also Star Wars the Last Jedi were a bit, well, rabid. There are definitely fair criticisms of both. I’d argue that the criticisms of the plot of TLJ were far fairer than some of the criticisms at GOT.
I never really felt that there were completely outlandish character flips in GOT series 8, that some claim. I do think, however, that people had their expectations subverted. Doing that is clearly really rather risky. I seem to love having my expectations subverted, generally.
I never really felt that there were completely outlandish character flips in GOT series 8, that some claim. I do think, however, that people had their expectations subverted. Doing that is clearly really rather risky. I seem to love having my expectations subverted, generally.