Still so much to unpack in this thread.
Has anyone ever seen Ashley Neal on YouTube? It could easily be said of Ashley that he is "cocksure" of himself. Clearly, however, he is not an idiot driver by any measure of the word.
This is why I take exception and offence to anyone conflating the attitude of "cocksure" with the automatic label of "idiot".
Yeah, sure, there are some cocksure idiots on the road and in my view this is a minority of the number of cocksure drivers out there. The trouble is that *YOU* just don't see the cocksure competents because their driving is not marking them out. They're inconspicuous. You *do* see the idiots, because they are conspicuous, and therefore the attitude of labelling the cocksure with the additional label of idiot is prevalent amongst those of limited analysis and reasoning. (And by extension those very people are virtue signalling that they believe themselves to be "better drivers" and in so doing become the hypocrite because what they are doing is, in fact, displaying their own cocksure attitude for all to see...)
Just to be clear, I don't see anything wrong, per se, with being a bit cocksure. I am myself. How does one justify that to oneself? Well, going back to the original discussion about hesitancy and nervous drivers... I am normally able to read the vast majority of other drivers around me, and know what they are going to do based on the body language of their driving. I'm pretty cocksure that I have skill enough to do this after many years of nurturing the ability. I can often tell what other drivers are going to do apparently before they know it themselves. For instance on a quiet 3 lane motorway with a vehicle ahead and a lorry well in front of that. I can tell that the car in front will need to pull out, often seemingly before they do themselves, so position myself in lane 3 well in advance and only when they are too close to the lorry do they start to cross the line and then might even indicate as an afterthought. You can see this happening well in advance if you are concentrating or if you are a competent driver. However, those many other drivers who approach the same situation as me and position themselves in lane 2 only to be conflicting with the driver needing to pull out into the side of them to pass the lorry that was clearly visible half a mile or more in advance... causing both drivers to get all angsty about right of way and who is in front or I was there before you idiocy... Oh, and neither are speeding - or cocksure - but both are idiots for sure, for not reading thje road and other road users...
With that in mind, I am happy to report that yes I'm a bit cocksure and can normally predict the vast majority of other drivers actions - even the cocksure idiots actions (possibly a hidden pseudonym for "boy racer"?) - because they are predictable.
Enter the nervous driver - this is where it gets sticky. I'm not talking about the recently passed a test hesitancy or young driver still learning the basics - you can tell those too - I'm talking the hesitant don't really know what they're doing types. Of all ages. This is where it gets sticky because those drivers are bloody unpredictable.
Personally, I'd very much rather be surrounded by the cocksure idiot and other cocksure competent drivers because despite the fact that I might not like their driving - at least they are largely predictable and therefore I can be safe around them. Not so with the nervous driver - it breeds a lack of overall safety. I just wish they'd learn better, because in the vast, vast majority of cases they could learn better if they had a mind to.