Red Dead Redemption 2 (PS4, Xbox and PC Hopefully)
- Thread starter Shawreyboy
- Start date
The console war is still going on I seehow many people really sink time into 360 games just because they've been enhanced.
Sit the fanbois down in front of two screens running this and most of them couldn't tell you the difference.
I actually just finished RDR on my One X using a 360 disc - looked very nice in 4k.
Second part I agree with, sort of. Pro and One X differences aren't as great as people make out in terms of graphical fidelity - both held back by poor CPUs. The noise of the Pro is though - the One X is on a different level as it stays pretty much silent on all games whereas my Pro often goes into Hoover mode when under duress.
I'm playing RDR2 on the One X and can't wait.
Owning both doesn't absolve you from posts you would typically see in a fanboy war that you've made in this thread. That's one of the classic excuses you see in the GPU section.
Soldato
- Joined
- 23 Mar 2011
- Posts
- 11,593
This thread is going down hill 
2 days folks
2 days folks
Soldato
- Joined
- 24 Sep 2013
- Posts
- 2,658
yeah RDR1 looks great on the X , and yes the fan on the X is silent whereas the PRO can really get wirring at times
Soldato
- Joined
- 24 Sep 2013
- Posts
- 2,658
Associate
- Joined
- 3 Mar 2010
- Posts
- 1,694
- Location
- Highlands, Scotland
Just curious, buy what exclusives have Sony managed to get from Rockstar regarding this release? Special items, missions etc?
The post about which will be better posted by someone that owns both consoles? I don't see how that's fanboyish at all. If they own both, how can they be a fanboy? Fanboyism is blind allegiance on one over the other, and most always results in the absolute refusal to buy the other.
Also, your comment was posted literally a few posts after my post saying about why I favour the Xbox One over the PS4 when I made my purchase. Nothing further up on this page makes any mention of preference of one over the other, so if you weren't referring to my post specifically, as you say you weren't, then what were you referring to? Or, as has been insinuated in here, did you just come in here to start something up? And to clarify, I wasn't defending anything. My post wasn't defensive, I was clarifying why I said what I'd said. It really is that simple. I do think you're just posting up to blow smoke and you should probably move on if you've got no interest in RDR2 or anything positive to add in here. You should also probably learn to know the difference between preference and fanboyism. Many in here favour one controller over the other, but that doesn't make them fanboys, but from your viewpoint it obviously must do.
And finally, I was the one that said earlier on in the thread about the console war, because at the time there genuinely was one going on. Posts that were referring specifically to which console won at release, blah blah blah. I don't really care about any of that. I based my purchase off the merits of what I mentioned in my previous post that you've accused me of defending myself in, and that was what made me swing toward the Xbox One for now. Anyone saying one console will look better than the other for a game that hasn't been released is just posturing. Nobody knows for sure until Friday comes along and people have it in the flesh.
I'm willing to bet the difference in visual quality will be so tiny that you wouldn't even notice. Rockstar are not going to develop 2 games for 2 machines, the game will be identical on both consoles and the difference will lie in OG PS4/Xbox One to Pro and X.. that's it.
For people joining the thread it's very simple, there are 3 things to base a console purchase on.
1, what are your friends on?
2, are there any exclusives that you need/want to play?
3, price, is it cheaper to own one or the other
Get what works for you, the power argument is only really relevant to exclusive titles. On multi platforms it will be negligible.
For people joining the thread it's very simple, there are 3 things to base a console purchase on.
1, what are your friends on?
2, are there any exclusives that you need/want to play?
3, price, is it cheaper to own one or the other
Get what works for you, the power argument is only really relevant to exclusive titles. On multi platforms it will be negligible.
Don't believe they have
It was pretty obvious what post it was referring to...
I'm interested in the game and enjoy reading the thread, without the same guy (that you've took it on yourself to defend) baiting with ****posts pretty much every day.
Soldato
- Joined
- 11 May 2007
- Posts
- 9,389
- Location
- Surrey
Both consoles have their pros and cons. Yada yada no one cares grow up, have a beer, smoke a joint, get on with life etc etc etc This is Red Dead PEOPLE!
Associate
- Joined
- 16 Jun 2011
- Posts
- 620
I get the feeling this game will push the pro and X quite hard. Spiderman and God of war make my pro sound like a jumbo jet talking off and for that reason alone I will be getting it on the X, The native 4K is just the icing on the cake.
Soldato
- Joined
- 24 Sep 2013
- Posts
- 2,658
they have a few elements of the game a month ahead of Xbox users, off the top of my head I cant recall the details
Not at all. I loved RDR though and have wanted more in a similar world since I finished playing it. The sense of openness that you get from roaming around on the plains is unparalleled, and it truly surprises me that no other game studio has expanded much on this sort of theme. It's like games about pirates. Assassin's Creed: Black Flag was amazing for the sea pirating, but nothing else is really around that does it anywhere near as well. I know Ubisoft are working on a standalone pirate title, but why no other studio has done similar is beyond me. How many have wanted to play a pirate or a cowboy when they were kids? A sandbox world in both gives us that ability, and that's why I'm looking forward to RDR2
Yup!
Quite the opposite Chris. It was tongue-in-cheek hence the smiley... or did you not see that? I chuckled at @CHokKA 's excitement of the impending release of RD2 hence my comment.
Stick it on Facebook as well with a shout out to Dave the delivery driver for "making your day".
I've not defended anyone, myself included. I spent time posting my reasons for why I purchased the Xbox and you've decided to respond in an antagonistic manner toward those posts for reasons only you know. It makes it seem like you have a gigantic chip on your shoulder about something that simply isn't going on in here. Anyway, perhaps go and take a break or something? You might feel a bit better when you're not mashing keys on your keyboard for the attention that you so clearly seek.
I don't think he was referring to you rhysduck. He wrote "fanbois" which is how Ayahuasca spelled it.
Anyway, back on topic. I've been watching my Amazon order page like a hawk. The bar is moving closer and closer to dispatch, and I'm willing it to move over but I know that's not going to happen today. Ah well, one can but dream!
What's the first thing that people are going to do once the sandbox bit opens up? I reckon I'm going to go out hunting!