Soldato
It really wasnt, probably the worst car BMW ever made.
Well thats not saying much is it really, cant see the wood for the trees and all that
Anyway, I didn't say it was a great car, its not, but I said the reviews were a bit OTT, which they were
Like for example the cabin size, its an issue the segment faces until they get really large, cars like the Juke get the same criticism, like by somehow jacking them up you should gain cabin space somehow. They are based on small chassis compared to how large the vehicle looks, but thats deceptive.
The segment is only really starting to mature now, plenty if not all the first gen of these SUVs were poor compared to normal cars in day to day use, apart from things like access.
They pretty much still remain so today, if you benchmark is a 5 series or something, they are all terrible.
If the OP was looking at a Q3 then the X1 is a valid competitor which if he hasn't driven one its worth looking at, particularly the new one as it has fixed a lot of the criticisms which were valid, just people went OTT about them
I guess it depends on what you consider the worst car and on what criteria, it seems Autocar for example disagrees with you, rating plenty of BMW cars with less stars than the v1 x1
Eg 1 series 3.5, x1 4
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/bmw/1-series-2011-2015
https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-review/bmw/x1-2009-2015/mpg