BF3 vs MW3

[Acolyte]

Just had my first game of MW3, its very arcadey fun and fast, but not a patch on BF3 puts it to shame IMO.

 

[gazzaa]

Ive got both and there great games.

 

[LabR@t]

sorry I thought i was in console forums.


now i checked i am not

 

[HAz]

BF3 is the game for me, no way im paying for mw3, overpriced console teen crap

 

[Soviet]

I love the CoD series for their SP storylines, but when it comes to MP; BF3 takes the cake for me.

IW really need to release the next CoD with a brand new engine because the last few games feel like expansion packs.

 

[~>Dg<~]

got both

bf3 i enjoy for playing with groups and the long battle.

cod mw3 is straight shoot kill fun when i cant be bothered to trek 15 mile to be killed by a lowtard hiding in a bush

both do there jobs nicely.

so i get both and am happy.

 

[McBain]

Got both...

BF3 for slower, team based gameplay

MW3 for fast arcadey style gameplay

Two very different games.

 

[Substance]

I bought both and although BF3 is really frustrating at times I am really enjoying both games

BF3 pros :-

Looks amazing
Spawn on squadmates
It really feels as though you are part of a team
Feels more "epic"
I have no problem with the controls

MW3 pros :-

Earning killstreaks,
You can jump on and know you can have a great full game in around 10 mins,
Much better single player
Way more game mode variety
More stable online (it seems this way from the few hours I have put into each)

 

[phatboy]

i have got both now. paid a combined 43 quid so havent paid over odds i dont think

bf3 so far is great but as said before has a brutal learning curve but worth sticking at. i havent touched sp

have mw3 downloading now and really looking foward to sp storyline

 

[Pighardia]

Got both...

BF3 for slower, team based gameplay

MW3 for fast arcadey style gameplay

Two very different games.

TBH if someone told me they wanted one of each of those types of game i would advise them to get MW2 over MW3! you can pic it up much cheaper now.

In other words, i agree with people saying about having 2 different types of games but a better question would be MW2 vs MW3, especially if you already have MW2

 

[OpenToSuggestions]

I have BF3 limited edition and it is going to become extremely epic when the re-makes of the BF2 maps are released near Christmas.
Karkand and Sharqi Peninsula are/were epic. Gulf of Omen was meh. Wake Island was almost always crap as the US would never get a base (had the aircraft carrier as an uncap).

From what I have read so far it seems MW3 is just a tarted up MW2 (MW2 was very good though). BF3 has plenty of flaws but one thing it isn't is a polished up BC2 (and cetainly not BF2 as it looks really dated now!), it is an entirely new game.

The only MW I have played online is the first one. To be honest I find the MW series single player very involving and very good, the BF3 one isn't the best (only a few hours into it) and the BC2 one was naff.

 

[Emjeadea]

i have both and think that cod has finally met its match bf3 is epic and cod has barely change but is still fun

 

[Efour]

BF3 makes me rage
MW3 makes me laugh

If i want to snipe ill play BF3 (bad rehash of bf2 not as good)
If i want to run around like a retard with throwing knives i play MW3 (rehash of MW2 and Cod4 lol...)

Both games were a complete let down - but both playable.

Both Genres are complete and utter turd now.

 

[~>Dg<~]

TBH if someone told me they wanted one of each of those types of game i would advise them to get MW2 over MW3! you can pic it up much cheaper now.

In other words, i agree with people saying about having 2 different types of games but a better question would be MW2 vs MW3, especially if you already have MW2

thing is lobbies on mw2 were utter lag fest i have played a lot of lobbies today on mw3 and they have been very smooth in comparison.

doesnt matter how good a game is if the lag is as bad as it was in mw2

 

[cyclonus10]

Played COD MW1 until COD MW2 came out, only played MW2 less than 6 months, all the perks and killstreaks felt bolted on, unlike MW1.
If MW3 is like a DLC for MW2 then i'll give it a miss.
If COD MW3 was more like MW1 then i would HAVE to get it.
People waiting until MW3 goes down in price, dont get your hopes up, i remember checking how much MW1 was 2nd hand a few months after MW2 was released and it was still £25-30.
By the time it reaches a low enough price for myself, everybody would have prestiged countless times already
BF 3 will keep me happy for a long time to come.

 

[dmcg]

both are nothing special or new but bf3 would be the better game

 

[BSmith]

Disappointed by both really. I really think DICE dropped the ball by trying to push it out to compete with MW3.

 

[PapaLazaru]

Dice have created Battlefield: Call of Duty edition.

lolwut

 

[oulton]

i like the look of mw3

Also, I suck at bf3

 

[oulton]

Starcraft 2 blows them all out of the water