BMW and M Power Owners

Noticed that my diff is having a very slow wee yesterday, caught an unmistakable whiff of diff oil and knew it wasnt going to be good news..
jfSNwPV.jpg
My first problem with the car, gutted :( Also shocked to see that it looks like it needs some attention under there with bits of rust! Wasn't expecting to see that, my E30 was much cleaner underneath, its just cosmetic from what I can see at the moment though so I'll add that to my agenda.

Anyway its the input shaft seal on the diff which has gone. I've got a quote for £310 for it repaired. Sound reasonable to you?? Sounds like a lot to me when it shouldnt be a diff out job and the seal itself is about £25-30.
I'd love to have a go myself but I'm far too busy at the moment and really could do with having it sorted.
 
[TW]Fox;28588472 said:
The 4GC looks good but is still fundamentally a 3 Series with its 1 Series style interior. The 5 series is a better car.

Fair enough, I've booked in to try both out in 30d variants so will see how it goes.
 
[TW]Fox;28588472 said:
The 4GC looks good but is still fundamentally a 3 Series with its 1 Series style interior. The 5 series is a better car.
eh? Surely you mean 1 series has a 3 series style interior seeing as 3 has been around a lot longer. Hate it when people get it the wrong way around.
 
Just wondered if anyone had experience of living with a 4 series gran coupe over significant mileage. I went to bmw yesterday to look at some 5 series but was quite taken with the looks of the 4GC, plus the slightly more practical boot however my main concern is comfort for the 25kish miles per year I'll be doing. any opinions?

I did about 27K / year for four years in an E91 and can confirm that it was perfectly comfortable for this, however a 5 series will of course be even more comfortable. The only thing you can do is try them both and then make your decision on an objective basis.
 
Anyway its the input shaft seal on the diff which has gone. I've got a quote for £310 for it repaired. Sound reasonable to you?? Sounds like a lot to me when it shouldnt be a diff out job and the seal itself is about £25-30.
I'd love to have a go myself but I'm far too busy at the moment and really could do with having it sorted.

Sounds a lot to me too, would have thought you'd be charged circa 2-3 hours labour plus the seal and fluid - get another quote
 
Last edited:
Sounds a lot to me too, would have thought you'd be charged circa 2-3 hours labour plus the seal and fluid - get another quote

Sounds a bit high to me too...get more quotes

Thanks for the responses! Hate to over-pay for the job but really struggling to find a reasonable, trustworthy and properly equipped mechanic locally and really need the car back on the road.

Might just have to bend over and take this one unfortunately. :(
 
my 330i has gone in for service today, i asked them to have a good look at the suspension/wheels as i am getting a good wobble on the wheel around 50mph and up. They say that everything is fine and recommend wheel balancing at £15 per wheel!

No thanks BMW.

I was thinking of getting the alignment etc done aswell and have had mentioned to be hunter wheel alignment. This worth doing? Ive not heard of it before.
 
A proper alignment can cure all manner of wobbles at speed and other symptoms such as uneven tyre wear, fuel economy quirks etc.

It can cost as little as £30 or as much as £75 from any decent place with Hunter kit. Local pro-Tyre here does it, I took my car in when I got it and they said it needed quite a bit of adjustment for all 4 wheels. Just shy of £70.
 
nearest play to me is nigel langs garage in bolton which seems to get very good reviews on a lot of owners forums which is good news :)

Im heading to williams bolton to pick me car up after dinner so will call in on the way back!
 
Just be aware, alignment on BMW's is a lot more complicated than people make out (especially those at tyre places who often have no clue how to do it!).

This is a post I did on M3Cutters about alignment:

Alignment thread said:
***Please be aware - this is a post relating to setting a car up as prescribed by BMW***

Having burnt through a lot of money over the past two months trying to get my alignment just right, I have learnt quite a bit about it, in particular, on the E46 M3. I have taken it to High Street tyre fitter depots, two recommended BMW specialists and finally Kwik Fit. The only person to get it right was a young lad at Kwik Fit, who didn't really know much about the in depth alignment needed on BMW's but took the time to learn about it. Because he was inexperienced, he didn't think he knew it all and followed the instructions to a tee, with me giving an input every now and then when he forgot something.

With the amount of time I have spent looking into alignment and the amount of money I have spent - the one thing that has become massively clear to me is that alignment is not about the machine used, is not about the experience of the person doing it, but is about the TIME and CARE spent on it, which I shall explain below:

- High Street tyre place - Had the latest Hunter alignment machine, but didn't even attempt to do Camber adjustment saying they needed some special tool (********) when really they just couldn't be bothered to do it because it takes too long. Done in 45 minutes.

- BMW specialists - Had a slightly older Hunter machine, but it was still very good. However, it was clear that they had rushed it through and not done it properly, even though they see E46 M3's on a daily basis, the level of care in their work just wasn't satisfactory and they left a lot of cross camber and toe settings were out when Kwik Fit checked it on their freshly calibrated Hunter machine 2 days later. Done in an hour.

- Kwik Fit - Young guy who hasn't been in the mechanic game long, didn't know much about E46 M3's or about how multi adjustable they were, but who spent ages on it getting it right and following the instructions, with my help. The alignment he did and the level of care in his work was exemplary. Took nearly 3 hours, but he did it so well and was learning as he went along. This proves you don't need to be an F1 mechanic to operate these machines properly, you just need to have some pride in your work and time to get it right. The actual machines are idiot proof. They tell you what to do, when to do it and even have videos showing you how to do it.

Right, so the practical part alignment. There is a LOT of people with misunderstandings about alignment, so I will try and make sure this thread is as factual as possible and without teaching anyone to suck eggs, go over everything to make sure you guys don't have to spend the time and money I did.

When you take your vehicle to an alignment place you must make sure of the following:

- You have a full tank of fuel.
- Your tyres are at the correct pressures (33FR/36RR for E46 M3 with standard 19's)
- Your bushes (FCAB, RTAB, rear ball joints) are in good order, and your track rods are not seized up.

When you get to alignment place, you must make sure they put the correct details of your car in. On every Hunter alignment it should read "E46 M3 - 19" alloys". If it says anything like "E46 Coupe with low slung sport suspension" they have got it wrong. The alignment specs they should be working to are:

Front:
-------
Camber: -1°20' to -0°40' (degrees/minutes)
Caster: 7°55' to 6°55'
Toe: 0°05' to 0°12'
Cross Camber (difference in camber across axle): No greater than 0.5° aka 30'

Rear:
------
Camber: -2°00' to -1°30'
Toe: 0°08' to 0°14'
Cross Camber - No greater than 15'

Prior to the alignment the car should be weighted down with 68KG in the front footwell/seat of each side and with 14KG placed in the boot. This brings the car to it's "Normal position". Now, people often think "Yep done, all weighted, ready to align the car" but don't understand what needs to happen next. Once the car is weighted the person undertaking the work should get the tape measure out and measure from the bottom of the alloy wheel (not tyre) to the highest point of the wheel arch.

The car should be brought to the following levels:

Front - 619mm
Rear - 600mm

If the car is within 10mm of these ride heights with the weights in when you measure it, you may proceed to balancing the car and bring it to "Design position". If not, the car must be repaired prior to the alignment.

"Design position" or balancing the car involves bringing each side of the car to within 1mm of the other side across the axle, which involves the removal and adding of weights as necessary. With my car, this involved putting 30kg in the drivers seat, but 60kg in passengers seat. With the rear of the car, this involved putting 75kg over the passenger side rear wheel, and none over the drivers side rear wheel. This brought the ride height completely level across each axle, and the Hunter machine could then take a reading. Straight away, 95% of the readings were in bang on in the green section, when they were not before after the previous 4 people had said it wasn't coming into line and they couldn't understand why.

From there, the rear camber and toe can be adjusted. Followed by the front camber and toe (in the right order).

This balancing of the car and ride height is critical to getting the right readings and is VERY often just skipped over by those doing the alignment - because they simply don't understand what they should be doing, even though it is on the screen in simple instructions. It is very simple and only took myself and the Kwik Fit guy 5 minutes to do - but just sticking in the ballast is only half of what needs to be done.

This is the ONLY way to align an E46 M3 and anyone else coming out with crap like "It'll only be you in the car most of the time, so we'll just weight the driver's seat" is wrong (on standard suspension and road conditions). BMW know best, they know it'll be you in the driver's seat most of the time yet they have tailored the specs to be how they are through their significant knowledge - trust them.

So now how does the car feel? They steering wheel is bang on straight, it takes the same amount of effort to turn left as it does to turn right, it does not wander at all and absolutely digs in like hell in the corners. The car is now set up correctly and you better believe you can feel it. I am happy again.
 
Last edited:
Still having some issues with my E46. The steering wheel shakes/wobbles over bumps and imperfections in the road which makes for an interesting ride. Another trait is when mounting the kerb the steering wheel will jolt even when on full lock. Feels like it goes past full lock when this happens.

I have already changed the inner and outer tie rods, control arms, steering coupler, drop links and arb bushes. Allignment has been done on a hunter machine as well.

Any ideas what else to try? I am thinking front shocks possibly or maybe the rack. Not had much luck with any garage finding the problem.
 
I had the exact same issue when i got mine and it turned put to be the front n/s shock which was completely goosed, even though there was almost no sign of leakage.

This was the o/s shock which was ok -https://youtu.be/Jwl7v4pdWHc

And this was the failed shock - https://youtu.be/u-ONSy7pSYk

Sounds promising, thank you. It didn't click at first that something like shocks could cause issues with the steering.

Any particular brand you would recommend or just stick to OEM?
 
Can anyone reccomend good pads? The OEM ones are so dusty! Just about to clock over 50k by the way since I got the 330d. Absolutely in love with it. Not a single issue so far, need to get the tracking done still, as it's pulling to the left slightly. Had the AC re gassed, air channels cleaned out (lots of leafs) and anti bac'd. I do a lot of motorway miles and a lot of central London driving. So it's filthy most of the time. I probably won't even try to give it a decent clean until Spring. I'll do a typical wash and wax next weekend. But it will be the last.

I got the car with 44k miles on the clock. Once I tick over 50k, I'll do an oil service as the last time it had one was at 42k. I'd rather do one 4k before the dealership service. 12k is too much for a diesel.
 
Back
Top Bottom