Yeah I cant believe they used this... but this also means that if you are using properly crimped cable you should be safe - and hence why there are no reports of melting with native cables.
-
Competitor rules
Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.
Check Your 4090's 12vhpwr Connectors To Make Sure They are in Pristine Condition
- Thread starter EastCoastHandle
- Start date
Please please tell me someone is having us on with that picture... even as someone who just does electronics like that as a hobby I know it is an unbelievably dumb thing to do.
Last edited:
Regardless I've always said it's super ugly and wouldn't use it for free
Unbelievable :/
Last edited:
Yeah no he's wrong, just look at some of his statements
"Standard compliant power supply cables from brand manufacturers are NOT affected by this so far."
This is false, cables from Corsair and Be Quiet have already shown to be affected and Nvidia did not design this cable, it was actually designed by Intel as part of their ATX3.0 spec
Here is a Be Quiet cable
Here is a Corsair cable
Trusts an engineer vs some random guy on a forums opinion
Associate
- Joined
- 29 Jun 2016
- Posts
- 530
To my eye those looked crimped and not soldered, or have I got that wrong? I guess the next argument is what is the margin applied on the continuous current rating of the connector.
For these sorts of connectors, I'd be tempted to uprate such that the loss of 1 contact was still within spec. It's pretty common, without special retainers that some manufacturers provide, that you get a bad insertion or the crimp's pawals are damaged and you get a partial contact.
The whole situation reeks of the connector spec being abused, i.e. not conforming to maximum AWG sizes, hence you just solder instead of crimp. This is pure speculation, but if this came onto my desk (where I have recently worked on several custom connectors, cables and looms), that's how I would read it...
Associate
- Joined
- 29 Jun 2016
- Posts
- 530
Common retention solutions for such connectors:
This is for the DuraClik Molex range. I couldn't be arsed finding higher current connectors, but it gives an idea of how a properly made cable assembly thats going to be manhandled would be designed/manufactured:
This is for the DuraClik Molex range. I couldn't be arsed finding higher current connectors, but it gives an idea of how a properly made cable assembly thats going to be manhandled would be designed/manufactured:
Soldato
But if you’ve spent £1700+ on a product, I think it’s fair to assume that the items supplied with it work and are safe. Fair enough buy another cable if you want better aesthetics but it shouldn’t be a necessity!
I am sure there are some excellent posts in here from people with real soldering and electronic qualifications and experience. I am here to give this thread balance from the idiots viewpoint and when you are selling to the general public an item that can consume upto 600w then it has to be idiot proof.
When there are 10s of thousands of these cards in the hands of every Tom Dick and Jane you will at times find them used in less than ideal situations and the connector has to be robust enough that it is almost impossible to use it wrong. The 3000 series connector was ugly and stupid as hell and it has not improved with this generation. Yes there were issues moving from molex to 6/8 pin connectors back in the day but for over a decade we had an idiot proof power delivery method and Nv decided to add in danger and risk and that is just stupid.
What they should have done right from the 3000 series launch with this new connector is put proper 90 and 180 degree adapters in the box that totally remove all risk and make it idiot proof for the average Joe like me. As it currently stands you are paying over £1600 for an electronic component that you have to goto Cablemod to get the proper adapters and cables to make it safe, that is pathetic penny pinching imho.
When there are 10s of thousands of these cards in the hands of every Tom Dick and Jane you will at times find them used in less than ideal situations and the connector has to be robust enough that it is almost impossible to use it wrong. The 3000 series connector was ugly and stupid as hell and it has not improved with this generation. Yes there were issues moving from molex to 6/8 pin connectors back in the day but for over a decade we had an idiot proof power delivery method and Nv decided to add in danger and risk and that is just stupid.
What they should have done right from the 3000 series launch with this new connector is put proper 90 and 180 degree adapters in the box that totally remove all risk and make it idiot proof for the average Joe like me. As it currently stands you are paying over £1600 for an electronic component that you have to goto Cablemod to get the proper adapters and cables to make it safe, that is pathetic penny pinching imho.
Last edited:
You're right, they should be safe and work. I think the design of the adapter to allow compatibility with current spec PSUs is sound but they obviously haven't been made to a high standard.
Associate
I've been using this since day 1 no issues, should I be worried now? Much neater than the adapter and can't see any bend.
Fasgear PCI-e Gen 5.0 Power Cable - 70cm 12VHPWR 16-pin 3x8pin(6+2 pin) Male Sleeved Cable - 600W GPU Power Cord for RTX 3090Ti & 4080 4090 Series
Fasgear PCI-e Gen 5.0 Power Cable - 70cm 12VHPWR 16-pin 3x8pin(6+2 pin) Male Sleeved Cable - 600W GPU Power Cord for RTX 3090Ti & 4080 4090 Series
TLDR here seems to be:
1. If you're using an ATX3.0 PSU with it's own 21vHPWR connector, you're fine
2. If you're using cable mods custom cables, you're fine
3. If you're using the Nvidia adaptor, make sure it's completely straight with no bends, consider options 1 or 2 if this isn't possible with your case.
1. If you're using an ATX3.0 PSU with it's own 21vHPWR connector, you're fine
2. If you're using cable mods custom cables, you're fine
3. If you're using the Nvidia adaptor, make sure it's completely straight with no bends, consider options 1 or 2 if this isn't possible with your case.
Soldato
Doubt it, Nvidia did the same with the 3 series, high demand, short supply, keeps the price high.
Soldato
- Joined
- 19 Jan 2006
- Posts
- 4,551
Yeah no he's wrong, just look at some of his statements
"Standard compliant power supply cables from brand manufacturers are NOT affected by this so far."
This is false, cables from Corsair and Be Quiet have already shown to be affected and Nvidia did not design this cable, it was actually designed by Intel as part of their ATX3.0 spec
Here is a Be Quiet cable
Here is a Corsair cable
To be fair, connectors that look like that are quite common - I've seen cables like that since I started building computers across every different type of power connector I've used except SATA.
Cables like that are a quick fix, broken solder tabs on the NVIDIA supplied connector are not.
In fact, I'd wager that those cables used like that without manually fixing/ensuring good seating, would handle more current and generate less heat than the NVIDIA pad soldered crap.
EDIT: This is exactly what CableMod are worried about happening with their connectors too, given the small pin size, hence the "don't bend too close to the connector". Reseating them in these types of cables is possible, fixing the NVIDIA supplied adapters is not.
Last edited:
They've apparently also asked the AIBs to return all damaged cards and cables back to Nvidia now
just don't use the adaptor - if it's as weak and brittle as Igor implies then you can damage the cable just by bumping or dropping it, you don't even need to bend it to break the soldered points off and you have no idea off he adaptor is already broken when you receive it as it can be broken in the box.
Last edited:
Soldato
Can you clarify this point?
Caporegime
- Joined
- 18 Oct 2002
- Posts
- 30,070
Which PSU do you have m8?