Right, this is my "review" of internet dating so far. I've been on PoF for a few days now just to say "I've tried it". I'm not Brad Pitt but I'm not an uggo either. I'm a 6/10 on a good day so I don't waste my time messaging the really hot ones, so I go for the ones who I would normally chat to on a night out. I've had some nice girlfriends in the past and while I'm not a "player" I have no problem chatting and flirting with girls on a night out. But online dating appears to be a whole different ball game...
I'd say my profile is at least mildly amusing. I made an effort not to sound too serious so it's light hearted while listing my interests. Oh and I ticked the box that I'm said I'm not looking for sex(!).
I've had 9 messages so far. Now even though my interests include tennis, snowboarding, running and coupled with my build type listed as "athletic" (which is true), 5 of them were at least a couple of stone overweight and 2 of them were very overweight. Clearly they are not interested in being active so not sure why they bother messaging me at first but I'll come back to this in a moment.
The remaining 2 were nice looking and in fairly good shape. The first one sent me something innocuous like "Nice profile, how was your day?". I replied with an anecdote about something funny that happened the day before and then nothing. No reply!
I exchanged a few messages with another girl, she seemed really chatty and we got on well. Last night around 12:30 I told her I had to go to bed because had to be up at 7 for work. Once again, nothing. The conversation wasn't peetering out, it was going well with long messages from both of us so it made no sense.
Finally, here is the best one of the lot. I was bored one night and spotted someone who had looked at my profile without a photo. So I thought what the hell I'll throw her a bone (no, not that kind you dirty people) and sent her a jokey message. The next day I get the old "Read - Deleted". Bear in mind that this is a user with no photo so is probably ugly or very shy and it's highly doubtful she gets many messages and here's the kicker - in order to message her she has specified that YOU must have a photo! I sent her a sarcastic follow up message about hypocritical photo requirements and advised her where the "block user" button was
So my conclusions so far for women in their 20's on PoF:
- The majority of women on PoF are overweight (I'm not being mean, it's just a fact)
- Lots of them have kids (not sure on numbers - say 1 out of 4?)
- The hot ones get 100's of emails per day so unless you are a very attractive guy you WILL be ignored
- The male to female ratio is around 5:1 so even the ugly ones start getting picky
- Many women are just looking to feed their ego. Once they get a reply they'll think "ok so I could have this guy if I wanted, now let's see if I can do any better". I doubt if some of them are even single.
- Being funny helps a little but looks are far more important. Yes most women are superficial despite what they say. Men are too but at least we are up front about it
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3c2e7/3c2e7078a9869e9d518813af2d0fa6f2837eea4d" alt="Big Grin :D :D"
Perhaps the same applies to men, but we'd need a female perspective to post something on that.
So don't waste your time, go join a tennis club, take a dancing class, do circuits... just do something that will get you interacting with women in real life because they all put internet dating to shame. I met my last 2 girlfriends playing tennis and doing circuits at uni and they were far more attractive than the girls who reject me on PoF!